TV Home Forum

X Factor: 2011

THE WINNER IS.......... Is there a X factor 2012? (April 2011)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
BA
Badger264
Because you do not base the decision on which people to have on how successful they've been. There is a lot more to it than that. After all, the premise of the show is that the contestants are mentored by the judges, so personality is a HUGE factor.

If Kelly Rowland had a personality suitable for the show we would've heard a lot more from her than we have over the last 10 years.

Tulisa on the other hand, is an inspired choice. She is warm, personable, current and most importantly, there are very low expectations generally so there is no chance she will disappoint.


Kelly has been on Xtra Factor quite a few times, she also judged the judges houses stage of Australian X Factor, so I'm sure the producers have seen enough personality to hire her. She always comes across very well in interviews, so she'll do fine. The producers haven't just plucked her off a list. Just because someone isn't in the press every two minutes doesn't mean they aren't suitable for such programmes.
Last edited by Badger264 on 30 May 2011 6:59pm
AC
aconnell
What is Cheryl going to do with herself now?! Eat Digestives until she gets depressed and fat?
BA
Badger264
What is Cheryl going to do with herself now?! Eat Digestives until she gets depressed and fat?


She's already too fat, according to FOX executives.
CH
Chie
The infamous sources say she's hardly eating.
BP
bpmikey
She's not exactly made it over here as a solo star.


I'm pretty sure she had a number 1 sometime last year with When Love Takes Over?
RO
rob Founding member
She's not exactly made it over here as a solo star.


I'm pretty sure she had a number 1 sometime last year with When Love Takes Over?


And a number one with Nelly in 2002.
DB
dbl
Commander..
BP
bpmikey
dbl posted:
Commander..


Another hit, yes!
IS
Inspector Sands
What is Cheryl going to do with herself now?! Eat Digestives until she gets depressed and fat?

The next Kerry Katona in the making?
MD
Mr D'Arcy
What is Cheryl going to do with herself now?! Eat Digestives until she gets depressed and fat?

The next Kerry Katona in the making?


From L'Oreal to Iceland eh? Laughing
DB
dbl
I guess ITV2 will welcome her with open arms! Laughing
TH
Thomas
She does still have her solo singing career though, doesn't she? She has more time to work on her next album now, surely?

Newer posts