TV Home Forum

The X Factor

Sharon quits The X Factor (March 2007)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
JA
jamesmd
rob posted:
Just heard the full version of Leon's new single on the radio and it's complete and utter ****e. I sincerely hope Katie Melua/Eva Cassidy stay at number one next week.


I don't. It's in incredibly bad taste and Katie Melua's shouty whiney style absolutely ruins Eva's beautiful voice.

F*ck off back to Beijing, Katie - they've got even more bicycles now, apparently.
ST
steddenm
From BBC News:

Arrow Media watchdog Ofcom is looking into complaints from X Factor viewers who claim they could not phone in to vote for eventual runner-up Rhydian Roberts.
The Welsh singer was hot favourite to win, but narrowly lost to Leon Jackson on Saturday night's ITV1 show.

Ofcom has had 80 viewers' complaints, and some fans told the BBC they tried and failed to vote up to 10 times.

The programme's production company said the high number of calls meant some people were greeted by engaged tones.

An Ofcom spokesman said viewers had "expressed concerns about the operation of the voting and many said they were struggling to get through".

Some radio stations in Rhydian's native Wales said they would boycott the winner's single and demanded a recount.

Scotland's Leon won the ITV1 show and a £1m recording contract, beating Rhydian, who had been the 1/3 favourite.

But viewers who had tried to vote for Rhydian, 24, from Sennybridge, Powys, insisted the phone lines were constantly busy during Saturday night's live final.

Gwyneth Greenslade, from Llandrindod Wells, Powys, told the BBC News website she had phoned 10 times and could not get through.

Her two friends also tried seven and 10 times respectively - and they too failed to register a vote.

"If you ring 10 times you expect to get through - I was very cross," said Mrs Greenslade.

"A lot of other people in this area said they couldn't get through. It seems to be very unfair."

Andrew Powell, from Abergavenny, e-mailed BBC Wales to say he and his family tried ringing to vote for Rhydian for an hour-and-a-half, only to be told the network was busy.

He wrote: "If the 'network' was busy then surely the amount of votes could not accurately be counted as the possibility of thousands of other voters that could not get through may have altered the outcome."

Fans on website message boards also complained about being unable to get through to vote for Rhydian.

A group of radio stations in Wales - including Bridgend's Bridge FM, Swansea Bay Radio, Radio Carmarthenshire and Radio Pembrokeshire - said they would ban Leon's Christmas single over the voting.

The stations, which are part of the Town and Country Broadcasting group, said they wanted a recount after being inundated with calls from their listeners about the busy phone lines.

X Factor production company Talkback Thames admitted some viewers trying to register their votes were met with the engaged tone, but blamed it on the sheer volume of calls.

"As all numbers go through to the same lines and vote platform, it is impossible for there to be any bias in favour or against a particular contestant," said a spokeswoman.

"Phone lines were monitored throughout the night and there were no issues on voting lines.

"We do get a huge surge of calls and depending on phone operators some callers may have experienced an engaged tone or network busy message and therefore may have to call back, but these calls should not be charged.

"Some Virgin Media customers did experience problems getting through because of high call volumes, but there were no other reported faults on the lines."

A Virgin Media spokesperson said: "We are currently looking into the X Factor matter but so far have not found anything unusual.

"However, we do know that the large volume of calls meant that some viewers had to keep redialling in order to get through. This is not unusual, for any of the telephone networks, for this type of mass voting event."

Arrow © 2007 BBC News

Oh dear, the X Factor has done it again...
:-(
A former member
come on the welsh bloke has got the better deal,

he not POP type, he will now get alot of broadway work!
AN
Andrew Founding member
what a load of rubbish. I remember this story back when it was Will v Gareth, of course some people are not going to get through, the lines were obviously very busy
TO
Tom0
tillyoshea posted:
Tom0 posted:
Brekkie Boy posted:
... As for 2008 - Louis and Sharon need to go, with one or two new judges bought in. I'd also liked to see it revamped so judges have acts from each category, rather than one category each.

Show wise the theme weeks need to end, as do the sob stories. They should definately stick to three in the final though - makes a much better event than just the two.


I don't think Sharon should go as she actually bring something to the panel, Louis is just making up numbers and is awful and needs to go.

I would like a fourth judge to be brought in, but I would only like to see 3 categories. I think one judge should be impartial.


How about Simon as impartial head of the panel with the casting vote? It would circumvent the jibes made especially by Sharon that it's unfair that she has no say about what goes on, whereas 'it's Simon's show'.


... and because it is him who is finding acts for Sony BMG, then he should be unbiased towards the other acts. I think it makes every sense for Simon to an impartial judge.
JA
jamesmd
Well of course the lines are going to be "jammed" - with audiences of around 10 million, and about half of those people stupid enough to vote in, the line traffic will be abysmally huge!
BB
BBriscoe
When I voted from my mobile I could get through, but I couldn't on my land line. So therefore it's obviously a problem with the service provider (Virgin Media in my case) and not with the production company and their phone provider.
PT
Put The Telly On
Tom0 posted:
tillyoshea posted:
Tom0 posted:
Brekkie Boy posted:
... As for 2008 - Louis and Sharon need to go, with one or two new judges bought in. I'd also liked to see it revamped so judges have acts from each category, rather than one category each.

Show wise the theme weeks need to end, as do the sob stories. They should definately stick to three in the final though - makes a much better event than just the two.


I don't think Sharon should go as she actually bring something to the panel, Louis is just making up numbers and is awful and needs to go.

I would like a fourth judge to be brought in, but I would only like to see 3 categories. I think one judge should be impartial.


How about Simon as impartial head of the panel with the casting vote? It would circumvent the jibes made especially by Sharon that it's unfair that she has no say about what goes on, whereas 'it's Simon's show'.


... and because it is him who is finding acts for Sony BMG, then he should be unbiased towards the other acts. I think it makes every sense for Simon to an impartial judge.


Are you related to Tom9 by any chance?
PT
Put The Telly On
steddenm posted:


Oh dear, the X Factor has done it again...


Indeed, would have been better if ITV didn't broadcast the show on TV this year and let the judges decide who wins. Rolling Eyes
BE
Ben Founding member
Andrew posted:
what a load of rubbish. I remember this story back when it was Will v Gareth, of course some people are not going to get through, the lines were obviously very busy


This is true and the lines were obviously busy for both as there wasn't the clearest of winners this year.

However there does seem to be an issue that you can find a lot of people to say they tried to vote Rhydion and fail but you can't find that many who said they had a problem when voting for Leon - that could be down to the fact they don't need to complain. It's an interesting situation but I suspect the number of complaints has been partially fuelled by the whole 'phone scam' thing going around right now.

Of course the whole thing is rigged every year Laughing
JE
Jez Founding member
BBriscoe posted:
When I voted from my mobile I could get through, but I couldn't on my land line. So therefore it's obviously a problem with the service provider (Virgin Media in my case) and not with the production company and their phone provider.


I tried voting for Rhydian 3 times and failed to get through. Im with VIrgin Media also. I dont think it was a fix though - the amount of people calling both lines were bound to be busy.
SE
Square Eyes Founding member
As has been said, big reality TV votes have always been subjected to busy lines, this is not a recent phenomenon.

The ability to get through on landlines can depend on your service provider, and your local telephone exchange.

Telephone voting is not an exact science, it's never going to be 100% accurate by it's very nature, but it's the best we have. The only alternative would be to give a longer period of time for the votes to be accepted. Then you lose the immediacy of the result and the event, if you are waiting a few days.

As for Leon votes, others have said they found it equally busy when attempted to get through to Leon, however that won't get mentioned.

It makes me smile when the people complaining say, "I got straight through to Leon" - no wonder he won, all these extra votes from people who didn't want to vote for him.

A few bitter people in Wales doesn't equal a fix.

Newer posts