TV Home Forum

The X Factor

Sharon quits The X Factor (March 2007)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
NI
Nicky
all new Phil posted:
I know I'll get mocked for this, but I think Same Difference are adorable. Absolutely love them. Unfortunately though, theres no way they'll ever make it after the show. I'm really glad Simon chose them though.


I really disliked them when they came in. Now I'm growing to like them... oddly enough.
BR
Brekkie
The Nurse posted:
Quite disappointed at the bottom 2 this week - I didn't agree that Futureproof's song was a bad choice and despite the obvious lack of dance routine (shame they decided to base the entire VT on the fact that there would be a routine only for them to pull it just before the show!) it wasn't a bad performance.



They were truly awful this week though - and worst of all was the excuse they only had 20 minutes to prepare. They'd had a whole bloody week!
NU
The Nurse
Yes I suppose you're right, that is no excuse.

The reason I was disappointed though was that they did a good vocal performance even if the "routine" was awful / non-existent. There were several other acts who gave a much less solid musical performance - ironically Hope being one of them!

One thing you have to remember about the groups is that they are all singing in harmony which is a skill in itself. All of the soloists can just learn a song off a CD whilst driving down the motorway then spend the rest of their time working on their performance and little touches like a routine. The groups have to be tought their harmonies individually (unless they're all sight-reading experts, which I doubt) then practise them so that they are totally solid before they can even begin thinking about their performance.
RO
rob Founding member
Brekkie Boy posted:
They were truly awful this week though - and worst of all was the excuse they only had 20 minutes to prepare. They'd had a whole bloody week!


Absolute crap. The worst week of X Factor so far. Having 20 minutes to improve was no excuse.
BR
Brekkie
The Nurse posted:
Yes I suppose you're right, that is no excuse.

The reason I was disappointed though was that they did a good vocal performance even if the "routine" was awful / non-existent. There were several other acts who gave a much less solid musical performance - ironically Hope being one of them!



To Hope's credit though, like Alisha last week they did seem to give a much better performance second time around while Futureproof were kind of resigned to their fate.


That result was never in doubt though - whether right or wrong Hope clearly have the potential to be far more marketable than Futureproof ever did.
BR
Brekkie
I think Niki might go tonight - first one on and pretty forgettable performance which nobody dared criticised as it was Kelly Clarkson.

Same Difference - they'd just annoyingly likeable and need to stick around a bit longer

Andy - vulnerable again tonight, but think he might scrape through.

Beverly - not sure myself, nowhere near as good as last week but think she'll be safe.

Hope - better than last week but quite boring once again

Leon - definately a far better performer than a couple of weeks ago but vocally not strong at all. This year's Ray Quinn though and he's probably safe again.

Alisha - good, but not perfect. The only thing saving her at the moment is being the only girl - but she wouldn't be missed.

Rhydian - absolutely outstanding tonight. Doing what he could feasibly be doing in his career. Kathryn Jenkins might be worried about her national anthem gig at the Millennium Stadium.


I definitely think Nikki will be in the bottom two - who against I'm not so sure, but I'd guess out of Hope and Andy. If Andy is there he's gone, but I think Nikki might go otherwise, providing the annual shock of the series.
JE
Jez Founding member
Same Difference are dreadful and should have gone a couple of weeks ago. That was their worst performance this week, an absolute mess.
OH
ohwhatanight Founding member
Jez posted:
Same Difference are dreadful and should have gone a couple of weeks ago. That was their worst performance this week, an absolute mess.


Im really warming to Same Difference! I think they totally captured the Scissor sisters ethos with the over-the-top performance.

Shame the VT on ITV2 made them cry.

Didnt realise Shayne was still going? Get rid of him!
AN
Ant
I noticed they don't seem to be showing the phone number when the acts are performing anymore. Complaints maybe?
:-(
A former member
wow My got it right again
AN
Ant
Andy and Beverly in the bottom 2 - Andy goes.

Good on Dermot for telling the audience to quieten down...
OH
ohwhatanight Founding member
Ive turned over to ITV2 for the Xtra Factor but it doesnt start until 21:45 tonight - any reaason why?

Newer posts