TV Home Forum

The X Factor 2008 - Official Thread

Alexandra WINS... JLS Second, Eoghan Third. (June 2008)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
NI
Nicky
SOL posted:
It looks like I'm in the minority as I will actually miss Sharon. They should just keep to the original format, with three judges.


Not just you; I'll miss her too. Just a shame she can't bear Danni! I do agree though that it should have stayed Simon - Sharon - Louis rather than add a fourth judge.
PR
Primetime
Bye, bye Sharon!

She can stay in America as far as I'm concerned. No great loss to the programme, their is no need for 4 judges in my opinion. Then again she will return in the 3rd or 4th audition programme.
SE
Square Eyes Founding member
I liked her for the first two series, but her bitter tantrums became increasingly tiresome and uncomfortable to watch. She wasn't that great at the role, the only judge never to win. Time she went.

I wonder if they'll get anyone else in ? As long as Cowell doesn't put a call in for his old friend Sinnita.
LL
Larry the Loafer
I felt Dannii never had any chemistry between the other three and found her rather useless. Nevertheless my opinion on Sharon has completely changed after the Brits so I wouldn't say I'm sad to see her go.

I'd like to see Piers Morgan give it a go, he's proven to be successful with BGT.
JO
Jon
Larry the Loafer posted:
I felt Dannii never had any chemistry between the other three and found her rather useless. Nevertheless my opinion on Sharon has completely changed after the Brits so I wouldn't say I'm sad to see her go.

I'd like to see Piers Morgan give it a go, he's proven to be successful with BGT.

No thanks, he hasn't proven successful, the format has proven successful because it a great format, it's just in unfortunate Moran involved with the production.
BO
Bongo
Maybe they should scrap x-factor next year or at least give it a year off. Im fed up of the winner getting christmas number 1 then seemingly dissapearing off the face of the planet for months and months on end.

The only good product of this show is Leona!
AN
all new Phil
It'd be nice to see a credible judge, someone who really knows the current music scene. I reckon Zane Lowe or Jo Whiley would make excellent judges.
TV
tvme
JCB posted:
Not really a huge fan of any of the judges but I found Osbourne more tolerable then the unbearably annoying Danni Minouge.

I fully agree with you Smile
SE
Square Eyes Founding member
Lulu has emerged as the bookies favourite to replace Sharon Osbourne.
FO
fodg09
Square Eyes posted:
Lulu has emerged as the bookies favourite to replace Sharon Osbourne.


Which would be a disaster,the only person who could make Dani seem any good.

I think I would rather them leave it with 3 judges.
:-(
A former member
BBCNicky posted:
SOL posted:
It looks like I'm in the minority as I will actually miss Sharon. They should just keep to the original format, with three judges.


Not just you; I'll miss her too. Just a shame she can't bear Danni! I do agree though that it should have stayed Simon - Sharon - Louis rather than add a fourth judge.


I can not stand that Danni Woman, I think Sharon was right, last year. Lets be honest lou was a lot better than other man He swapped with last year. He was right up his own backside that dancer bloke,

Has anyone else Mist the point???

Sharon was in GLASGOW a month ago doing auditions, so she will still be in the X factor
PT
Put The Telly On
By irony, a group are performing Shout as I type this!

The TV Show reported Paula Abdul was favourite to replace Sharon. Personally I agree, they should just stick with 3 judges.

Newer posts