TV Home Forum

The X Factor 2008 - Official Thread

Alexandra WINS... JLS Second, Eoghan Third. (June 2008)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
TO
Tom0
The ones that are talented this year are extremely talented, but we also have very average acts too. I think Alex, Austin, Diana, JLS, Laura and Rachel are all in with a shot, and I think Bad Lashes, Ruth and Scott are the ones to watch. However I think Danny, Eoghan and Girlband will all be gone in the first couple of weeks. I think its the best final 12 we've ever had, and is definitely the most open since series 2.
AN
all new Phil
At this stage, I think I'd like to put it on record that I think the Spanish girl will win. Not that I can remember her name Smile She just has "it".
SP
Spencer
TV Times posted:
I personally think this will be the weakest year yet - we have another Steve Brookstein in the shape of Danny - did he get through cause of his singing talent or his sob story?


I always feel really uncomfortable when he starts talking about his dead wife. There's just something about the way he's so keen to trot out the story that makes you feel he's rather exploiting the situation for his own gain.
BR
breakingnews
Spencer For Hire posted:
TV Times posted:
I personally think this will be the weakest year yet - we have another Steve Brookstein in the shape of Danny - did he get through cause of his singing talent or his sob story?


I always feel really uncomfortable when he starts talking about his dead wife. There's just something about the way he's so keen to trot out the story that makes you feel he's rather exploiting the situation for his own gain.


He'll be one of the first out I think. Unattractive and not a particularly amazing singer.
AN
all new Phil
It's always fun to try and predict who will be kicked out first. I'd say Rachel, I just don't like her and I can't see her coping well on stage.
BR
Brekkie
I don't think the public will like Rachel at all - not just for her demeanour and story (we're hardly a forgiving nation on such matters), but also as she's just not that great a singer.

Ruth isn't going to get anywhere too - one week the judges will moan at her for not bringing her Spanish roots to the stage, the next week they'll be claiming she's losing herself votes for singing in Spanish.


And as usual too the themed weeks won't work in any of the acts favours, though this year there aren't really any acts who seem to be of a certain genre. I do worry though Louis will go too far down the Motown route with JLS rather than something alot more modern.
BR
Brekkie
The odds from PaddyPower:

WINNER
Alexandra Burke 3 - 1
Laura White 3 - 1
Austin Drage 4 - 1
Diana Vickers 9 - 1
Rachel Hylton 9 - 1
Eoghan Quigg 10 - 1
JLS 12 - 1
Ruth Lorenzo 16 - 1
Danny Evans 20 - 1
Bad Lashes 22 - 1
Scott Bruton 33 - 1
Girlband 50 - 1

I'd say Scott looks a good bet there as the dark horse - and I'm surprised JLS aren't amongst the favourites.


Winning Judge
Cheryl Cole 4 - 5
Simon Cowell 9 - 4
Dannii Minogue 5 - 1
Louis Walsh 15 - 2

I'd have thought Dannii would be the outsider.


First Act eliminated
Girlband 9 - 4
Scott Bruton 4 - 1
Bad Lashes 9 - 2
Daniel Evans 13 - 2
Ruth Lorenzo 7 - 1
JLS 14 - 1
Eoghan Quigg 16 - 1
Rachel Hylton 18 - 1
Diana Vickers 18 - 1
Austin Drage 33 - 1
Laura White 40 - 1
Alexandra Burke 50 - 1


Next to step down or be axed
Dermot O'Leary 11 - 10
Louis Walsh 7 - 4
Danni Minogue 3 - 1
Holly Willoughby 6 - 1
Simon Cowell 50 - 1
BR
breakingnews
Scott is the definite dark horse among those stats. Cute and good personality (doesn't cry!) And I believe Austin is far too hyped and will lose out quick enough.

Girlband, Daniel or Rachel up for elimination in the first week with Girlband getting the boot from the judges is my prediction.
TO
Tom0
breakingnews posted:
Scott is the definite dark horse among those stats. Cute and good personality (doesn't cry!) And I believe Austin is far too hyped and will lose out quick enough.

Girlband, Daniel or Rachel up for elimination in the first week with Girlband getting the boot from the judges is my prediction.


I agree, but I think Ruth is another definite dark horse. Its going to be an exciting year, normally we can call it or say the three or so that its between but not this year. I also think it was stupid of Louis to put through 2 girl bands with 4 members in. For a lot of people I wouldn't be surprised if people get confused between the two, but I think Girlband will be kicked out in the first week.
BR
breakingnews
BTW a shame Hannah didn't get through.

Leon is singing his new song tonight I heard.
DA
davidmcg
Seen the video, looks like a different person altogether!!!! Song isn't another bleeding love but better than most of what Shayne Ward has churned out.
SA
salfordjohn
anyone to care to pick up these thoughts:

What was the point of putting 4 individual boys together in the hope they might work out together? At least last year when they did it the lads all lived in the same part of the country. But ths year it was never gonna work and surely meant it prevented an actual band who arrived and performed together from getting to the final stages.

When they changed their mind at bootcamp and brought Liam back in, they still only had their final 6 boys - surely they already had the 6 if Liam was initially rejected? So surely they must have changed their mind also on someone they had initially decided yes on? Why was this not explained? And last year - when they did the same thing - they took 7 acts further didn't they?

Newer posts