TV Home Forum

The X Factor

(September 2005)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
JE
Jez Founding member
marksi posted:
There probably aren't that many people called Jez who regularly post in topics about the X Factor and who have an irrational dislike of Shayne.


Ah but my username isnt Jez on DS Forums. And i dont have an irrational dislike of him, I just dont like him thats all. Is that not allowed?
PA
pad
Jez mate, I'm just saying your opinion changed quie rapidly. It might be because you think he got too cocky or something, but at first you loved Shayne, now you bitch about him whenever possible.

I won't say the J word.

Jez posted:
tvfreak posted:
Jez I really can't understand you!

You really bitch about Shayne now - on here and DigitalSpy's forums. At the beginning you liked him. I reckon you fancy him. Razz


I did like him but ive gone off him since the live shows, now he is too arrogant by far. And no I dont fancy him.

How do you know that is me on DS forums?


I just do. LOL if you don't believe me ... I've PMd you.
BO
Boleto
Bye Conways... I actually rather liked them. Think im the ONLY one...
PT
Put The Telly On
Good riddence to the Conways. Only one of them was a good singer - the tall larger one. I see the blonde one really hates Simon - moving towards Kate as he arrived on stage throughout the 'best bits'!

I'm a fan of Brenda and Andy myself, but if Andy wins - I fear, he'll go like Steve Brookstein. Not that this is what happens to most winners nowadays. I've probably said that time and time before.

Journey South are just...well....imageless.

As for Simon's court case, its like TV Forum taking the Digital Spy Forums to court.
NU
The Nurse
nok32uk posted:
Good riddence to the Conways. Only one of them was a good singer - the tall larger one.


I'm sorry this is rubbish. It's easy for people who don't know what they're talking about to use phrases like "bad singer" etc but few people seem to know what that actually means. What the Conways have done every week is far harder than any of the other acts - singing 4 part harmony throughout a song is NOT easy, and neither is it easy to learn it in just a week as they no doubt have most weeks

Having said all of that, I agree it's time that they were off. I thought they were good singers but I really don't think they had the "X factor" which is, after all, what it's all about. Simon voting off his own act was indeed a brave thing and definitely not something the other 2 would have done. He doesn't seem to have been really behind them much though recently.

And to that poster who thinks the whole thing is a fix - "WHATEVER" .
PT
Put The Telly On
Everyone's entitled to their view my friend. It is true, only one of them had X Factor potential though.
JA
jamesmd
nok32uk posted:
Good riddence to the Conways. Only one of them was a good singer - the tall larger one.

You're kidding, right? She couldn't hold the high D she was given in Nothing's Gonna Stop Us without her voice waving. And to others, I don't want all that claptrap about it being live on televisin in front of millions, etc... if you can't hold the notes, don't try singing them, love.
BI
bigbrothereire
Sat 26th November 2005
From MediaGuardian

Strictly Come Dancing 9.1m - 39%
Strictly Come Dancing Results 7.3m - 31%

The X Factor 8.1m - 35% (higher share of the 16-34 audience than Strictly)
The X Factor results 8.5m - 37%
PT
Put The Telly On
Jaimé Alexandéz posted:
nok32uk posted:
Good riddence to the Conways. Only one of them was a good singer - the tall larger one.

You're kidding, right? She couldn't hold the high D she was given in Nothing's Gonna Stop Us without her voice waving. And to others, I don't want all that claptrap about it being live on televisin in front of millions, etc... if you can't hold the notes, don't try singing them, love.


She could hold it. She managed very well, which is what made me take notice. The short auburn haired one was the worst and she had the opening line - terrible!
DA
David_02
Jez posted:
Ah but my username isnt Jez on DS Forums. And i dont have an irrational dislike of him, I just dont like him thats all. Is that not allowed?


I don't like him either. I think I know who you might be on DS, I could be wrong but it's quite an obvious username if it is you.

Back on topic, I hope Chico is gone this week, and that Brenda makes the final. Brenda is just amazing, so much better than Andy, who has not really challenged himself vocally, where as Brenda as had much more of a range of songs than Andy. I would realistically like Brenda, Journey South and Shayne, there's obviously no getting round the fact that he will be in the final and there's nothing we can do about it! Sad
BR
Brekkie
02cashindavid posted:
Back on topic, I hope Chico is gone this week, and that Brenda makes the final. Brenda is just amazing, so much better than Andy, who has not really challenged himself vocally, where as Brenda as had much more of a range of songs than Andy. I would realistically like Brenda, Journey South and Shayne, there's obviously no getting round the fact that he will be in the final and there's nothing we can do about it! Sad



It wouldn't surprise me if there was another shock in the next few weeks that saw Shayne leave.

It's a shame the judges voting stops this week - I'd say it be between Andy and Chico to go next week, and think Louis would vote out Andy, Simon would vote out Chico leaving it up to Sharron - and I haven't got a clue which way she'd go! She'd probably refuse again!
LU
Luke
Despite having the one of the more mediocre voices (imo) Shayne already has a record deal lined up, so it makes no difference whether he wins or not.

Newer posts