TV Home Forum

Watchdog

The programme you can probably afford to miss (November 2016)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
SO
SOL
SOL posted:
Watchdog was prerecorded? News to me Surprised


It was pre-recorded when it was in the tent, but only earlier that day (I think).


I didn't know that.

I remember the series when Ann Robinson returned was recorded and it was awful. It improved when it was a live show again on the following series. Programmes like Watchdog should always be live.
NG
noggin Founding member
SOL posted:
SOL posted:
Watchdog was prerecorded? News to me Surprised


It was pre-recorded when it was in the tent, but only earlier that day (I think).


I didn't know that.



It was pre-recorded, but the day before, not on-the-day.
NG
noggin Founding member
the Digital Production Partnership guidelines for completed programmes being delivered by file to all the major UK broadcasters says that a clock or slate can be used:
Quote:
Where a moving clock is used, it must provide a clear countdown of at least 7 seconds, including a hand moving in 1 sec steps (i.e. not smooth motion) around a circular clock face. Clocks with only digital countdown are not acceptable.


Obviously this doesn't apply to VT inserts, but I'd imagine post production houses would just apply the same rule to everything they churn out.


Most shows DO apply that rule to inserts if they use clocks. The use of sweeping second hands is the work of the devil - if you've ever tried cueing one...

Clocks are very useful if you need to mark an in on an ingested server clip in a hurry. Find the -5" point exactly (easy with a non-sweep clock), stripe it as 09.59.55.00 and you have a perfect 10:00:00:00 in point available... Much, much more useful than a slate.
KN
knack
First cock-up of the night. countdown into the Rogue Traders VT went out.


BBC Scotland cut to the technical difficulties slide then quickly cut to whats coming up later. Was very messy.

Hmm sounds over sensitive to problems.

No credits which I'm not a fan of. Prefer to know whose hard work was involved.

Someone read your post - credits were included this week.
LL
London Lite Founding member
Two weeks into this run and Watchdog seems to have found its mojo again. The move to Salford has helped the programme which after last year's 'tent' run is more focused and utilising the right presenters which proves it can have a post Anne Robinson and Chris Hollins future.

However I still wish Rogue was axed and given it's own 30 min slot instead.
Newsroom24 and Critique gave kudos
DP
D.Page
I thought Steph had a couple of black eyes last night, then I realised it was a case of too much make-up Very Happy

What's happened to the Rogue's Gallery, normally at the end of the final Rogue Traders Section? They've dropped it. Bring back Rogue's Gallery!

Oh, and this latest theme tune arrangement is not as good as the previous version.
HA
harshy Founding member
A little late to the vt discussion but do the BBC use vt clocks, I've never seen it on any live feeds, my favourite vt clock is the channel5 cricket highlights show which Geoffrey boycott tossing the cricket ball up into the air 😁
NG
noggin Founding member
A little late to the vt discussion but do the BBC use vt clocks, I've never seen it on any live feeds, my favourite vt clock is the channel5 cricket highlights show which Geoffrey boycott tossing the cricket ball up into the air 😁


BBC no longer use them at the start of live shows (too many were being cut up...) but recorded shows delivered as files or on tape will have them.

VT inserts for live shows will depend on the post production and playout systems, and how the material is delivered. It's certainly not unusual for a show with lots of inserts played out manually from EVS to have inserts with clocks delivered on them (it's easier to set an in point on a clocked item than a slated item quickly), but once ingested the in-point marked for the start of play in is likely to be first frame of pictures.

8 days later

DJ
DJGM
For whatever reason, last night's episode is not yet available on BBC iPlayer. Is there some technical or legal reason why it hasn't been uploaded yet? It's usually up within a few hours after broadcast. I missed the show last night. Did something go wrong?
NJ
Neil Jones Founding member
DJGM posted:
For whatever reason, last night's episode is not yet available on BBC iPlayer. Is there some technical or legal reason why it hasn't been uploaded yet? It's usually up within a few hours after broadcast. I missed the show last night. Did something go wrong?


Documented:

https://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/help/programme-availability/programme-issues/watchdog posted:

We're aware the episode of Watchdog broadcast on BBC One on 12/07/2017 is not available.

This is under investigation and we will update this FAQ when we have further information.
L8
L89
DJGM posted:
For whatever reason, last night's episode is not yet available on BBC iPlayer. Is there some technical or legal reason why it hasn't been uploaded yet? It's usually up within a few hours after broadcast. I missed the show last night. Did something go wrong?


The dogs in the studio had name tags and these have been blurred out on iPlayer. So not anything relating to companies investigated.
WO
Worzel
L89 posted:
DJGM posted:
For whatever reason, last night's episode is not yet available on BBC iPlayer. Is there some technical or legal reason why it hasn't been uploaded yet? It's usually up within a few hours after broadcast. I missed the show last night. Did something go wrong?


The dogs in the studio had name tags and these have been blurred out on iPlayer. So not anything relating to companies investigated.


They obviously couldn't sign on the dotted line to allow their names to be shown on subsequent repeats. Either that or one of them made a complaint. Barking mad if you ask me. Laughing

Newer posts