TV Home Forum

Top Gear

Moving to BBC ONE (February 2020)

IS
Inspector Sands
Jonwo posted:

The 2002 Top Gear is a completely different show to its predecessor which was a straight forward review show. So it’s somewhat correct.

Same name, same theme tune, same brand (the non Top Gear brand extensions continued), same production company... it's a continuation of the same programme just with a different format.
HC
Hatton Cross Central (West) Midlands Today
But which 'garage' is this going to be driven into in the BBC One schedules?
I'm really struggling to think of a suitable slot.
Sunday 8pm is drama/Antiques Roadshow territory.

Pre- Match Of The Day would be a) a bit too late and b) point the finger that it's going back to its male car driver roots.

Weeknight 8pm slot, doesn't seem the right fit, plus you've got some unmovable popular shows that have taken root in there.

So, thinking Countryfile at 6, Top Gear at 7 - but if you are looking for complimentary shows for a lead-in to it (not that it needs it as BBC Two audience will move across with no prompting) they are rather awkward bedfellows.
Last edited by Hatton Cross on 3 February 2020 5:39pm
Readers are warned that this post contains some flash photography
BR
Brekkie Wales Wales Today
Doesn't seem the right move really - it's home is Sundays 8pm and having it alternate with Call the Midwife or follow Strictly doesn't work.

If it moves nights Monday 9pm might be best - think it'll get lost later in the week.
Last edited by Brekkie on 3 February 2020 5:38pm
Turns out nobody had 2020 vision.
RW
Robert Williams Founding member London London
18 years? It went national in 1978. It was axed at the end of 2001 and returned in October 2002 so it's been on BBC2 for 42 years.


Pre 1978 it was a regional Midlands programme of course. Was it on BBC 1 or 2 during that period ? I don't think there were any BBC 2 English regional opts before about 1980 ?

Indeed - it was on BBC1 when it was a Midlands-only programme.
AN
Andrew Founding member Yorkshire Look North (Yorkshire)
This makes BBC Two look even weaker than it does already with no clear remit, it’s biggest shows taken from it, many hours just simulcasting the news channel.

Airing it at Sunday at 8pm will be a right gear change, alternating with Antiques Roadshow and airing after Countryfile. The elderly audience that makes up the biggest chunk of the viewers on a Sunday night won’t know what hit them.
CA
Cando London London
Airing it at Sunday at 8pm will be a right gear change, alternating with Antiques Roadshow and airing after Countryfile. The elderly audience that makes up the biggest chunk of the viewers on a Sunday night won’t know what hit them.


Well if they can survive Peaky Blinders and Line of Duty, I imagine they can survive Top Gear.
NT
NorthTonight North Reporting Scotland
Remember they tried QI for a while on BBC One and shifted it back to Two? Sometimes things don’t fit on another channel.
CA
Cando London London
Remember they tried QI for a while on BBC One and shifted it back to Two? Sometimes things don’t fit on another channel.

It fitted in fine and doubled its ratings, it only went back because the then controller of BBC ONE Danny Cohen didn't like it and wanted to free up development cash. Which ironically was mostly spent on a reboot of the old BBC 2 format Room 101.
WM
WMD Meridian (Thames Valley) South Today
18 years? It went national in 1978. It was axed at the end of 2001 and returned in October 2002 so it's been on BBC2 for 42 years.


Pre 1978 it was a regional Midlands programme of course. Was it on BBC 1 or 2 during that period ? I don't think there were any BBC 2 English regional opts before about 1980 ?


Genome to the rescue: BBC1 Midlands.
https://genome.ch.bbc.co.uk/schedules/bbcone/london/1977-04-22
MA
Markymark Meridian (Thames Valley) South Today
WMD posted:
18 years? It went national in 1978. It was axed at the end of 2001 and returned in October 2002 so it's been on BBC2 for 42 years.


Pre 1978 it was a regional Midlands programme of course. Was it on BBC 1 or 2 during that period ? I don't think there were any BBC 2 English regional opts before about 1980 ?


Genome to the rescue: BBC1 Midlands.
https://genome.ch.bbc.co.uk/schedules/bbcone/london/1977-04-22


Ta!

Interesting that after 23:15 the listings switch to minute accuracy
Last edited by Markymark on 3 February 2020 7:58pm
--
Avatar credit: © BBC, ITA, BREMA 1967
MS
Mr-Stabby London London
Jonwo posted:

The 2002 Top Gear is a completely different show to its predecessor which was a straight forward review show. So it’s somewhat correct.

Same name, same theme tune, same brand (the non Top Gear brand extensions continued), same production company... it's a continuation of the same programme just with a different format.


Oddly if you watch the first series of the rebooted Top Gear, other than the fact it had studio segments and the star in a reasonably priced car, it was closer to the original format compared to what it became. The first report they did was a long segment about how reasonably priced A converted Citroen van was. That's why i've always considered it the same show from 1978.
JA
JAS84 Yorkshire Look North (E.Yorks & Lincs)
So, thinking Countryfile at 6, Top Gear at 7 - but if you are looking for complimentary shows for a lead-in to it (not that it needs it as BBC Two audience will move across with no prompting) they are rather awkward bedfellows.
Couldn't the same be said for Countryfile and Doctor Who, which is currently on that same timeslot?

Newer posts