TV Home Forum

Swap Shop Returning?

It’s believed the BBC will make an announcement in December (October 2007)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
RE
Reboot
noggin posted:
I think the major issue would be giving kids names and addresses to total strangers who rang in. (If that is how it used to work - and I think it was)

In the last 15 years or so , even showing kids paintings on air requires you to remove or mask their names and addresses (hence the request to write it on the back not the front...)
noggin posted:
Assuming the BBC own the rights to the format - then I suspect that most issues would be towards the BBC arbitrating contracts between two people. (What if the toys swapped don't have CE marks etc.), and privacy issues for kids.

The world has changed - in perception, if not reality - since the 70s.

Yep & Yep.
JA
jamesmd
Well the privacy issue is fairly straightforward - instead just send the swap items to the Beeb and the middleman will send them back out to their respective parties.
BU
buster
If it is brought back - and is on Saturday mornings - it'll be interesting in the sense that until now it appeared that TMi is the only show they'd run on Saturday mornings, and only for about four months a year. It'd be nice to have something back for the rest of the time. (although no doubt it'd only be an hour long or something silly like that)
FA
fanoftv
buster posted:
If it is brought back - and is on Saturday mornings - it'll be interesting in the sense that until now it appeared that TMi is the only show they'd run on Saturday mornings, and only for about four months a year. It'd be nice to have something back for the rest of the time. (although no doubt it'd only be an hour long or something silly like that)


Yeah, I was thinking along these lines. I'm not sure that I like the idea of Basil Brush presenting, it's a shame that Ed is doing CBBC Continuity as someone with his sort of personality would be great imo.

It is a shame for TMi, as they have had their run and time reduced since last year, more so its the fact that it seems that they are (if rumours are true) willing to put money into saturday morning, but they didn't seem to do it for TMi, it could have worked brilliantly on a bigger scale, though I suppose studio 9 could be to try and recreate the leicester sq idea from series 1.
TV
tvarksouthwest
James Hall posted:
Well the privacy issue is fairly straightforward - instead just send the swap items to the Beeb and the middleman will send them back out to their respective parties.

Exactly what I was going to say.

Though I'm surprised the Beeb didn't act as middleman in the first place.
JC
JC2
I have to agree it is a shame for TMi. If it does return for a third series, I'm hoping the BBC recognises the programme's potential and extends the programme's run. However, given the circumstances, I thought TMi have done well to put on programme like they have.
RU
russnet Founding member
fanoftv posted:

Yeah, I was thinking along these lines. I'm not sure that I like the idea of Basil Brush presenting, it's a shame that Ed is doing CBBC Continuity as someone with his sort of personality would be great imo.

It is a shame for TMi, as they have had their run and time reduced since last year, more so its the fact that it seems that they are (if rumours are true) willing to put money into saturday morning, but they didn't seem to do it for TMi, it could have worked brilliantly on a bigger scale, though I suppose studio 9 could be to try and recreate the leicester sq idea from series 1.


I think the run is the same as last year. 20 weeks. The only difference is that this year they started a few weeks earlier. As for the duration, yes the show is 30 minutes less but there is less time for additional programming within TMi such as no Prank Control which was normally around 15-20 minutes long. The inserts such as the Thumb wrestling and Headz must be no more than 10-15 minutes in duration.
JB
JasonB
This bit made me laugh:
The Sun posted:
What’s really great that it’s a return to a live children’s show set in a studio – which we haven’t had for a while.


Have they been watching the wrong channel?

I wonder how long before Noel Edmunds is the weeks guest on the new Swap Shop? Laughing
JW
JamesWorldNews
Will it still be Multi-coloured?
JO
Joe
BBC WORLD posted:
Will it still be Multi-coloured?


Doubt it - seems a bit unneccesary to have 'multi-coloured' in the title these days.
SO
Steven O
noggin posted:
From memory Swap Shop had two swapping methods.

1. There was a list of stuff people had rung in that they wanted to swap, and what they wanted to swap it for. Other people rang in offering to do this. I've always assumed they gave the two people each others phone numbers or addresses. However giving out kids addresses to strangers would not be acceptable in this day and age... E-mail or phone number may be OK.

2. Keith Chegwin used to present OBs from around the UK, where people would bring stuff they wanted to swap, and at the OB Keith would get people up on stage with what they wanted to swap, and match them with other people in the crowd who had stuff they wanted to swap.

The key thing about Swap Shop wasn't really the swapping, it was that kids could ring in, not just to swap stuff, but to ask questions of the guests in the studio, which was really quite radical for the BBC at that time (in fact for telly in general)


There were certain things that you couldn't swap - for instance, your sister for a brother, a Mini for a Ferrari, or a budgie for a vulture. Quite why you would want a pet vulture is anyone's guess. Laughing
NG
noggin Founding member
James Hall posted:
Well the privacy issue is fairly straightforward - instead just send the swap items to the Beeb and the middleman will send them back out to their respective parties.


You don't seriously believe the BBC would staff a warehouse operation to deal with thousands of incoming and outgoing packages do you? How could you justify the expense to the licence-fee payer? It certainly wouldn't be something you could give a runner to do for an afternoon...

Also In the current security climate there is no way they would do this. Can you imagine having to X-Ray that many packages - and search them? (Most large packets sent to the BBC are still X-rayed... After all a bomb went off outside TV Centre relatively recently)

Couple that with any legal responsibility the BBC might have in acting as a mediator for a contract between two parties - and you can guarantee a legal can of worms.

Newer posts