TV Home Forum

Stuart Murphy has resigned

Controller - BBC THREE moves to RDF Media (October 2005)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
NG
noggin Founding member
Inspector Sands posted:
DJGM posted:
Good riddance to the man that stupidly axed Liquid News is all I can say to this . . .


Even though he's the same man who launched Liquid News in the first place?!


Yes - though Liquid News was, in reality, a development of Zero 30 (same production team, same presenter) which launched on News 24. Stuart backed it, and gave it a home and a better budget, and then axed it.
IS
Inspector Sands
tvarksouthwest posted:

So a man who makes his channel unwatchable by littering it with screen junk is one of the BBC's "finest controllers"?


Of course some of us have the concentration span that enables us to watch the programmes!

He was a good controller in the sense that he is a visionary - I always got the feeling that unlike some other he looked at channels as a whole entity rather than merely scheduling the programmes. There are very few people who have been given a whole BBC channel to format and create - Murphy did it with 2 (if you count UK Play). Certainly it's some achievement to be running a channel at the age of 26
IS
Inspector Sands
noggin posted:
Yes - though Liquid News was, in reality, a development of Zero 30 (same production team, same presenter) which launched on News 24. Stuart backed it, and gave it a home and a better budget, and then axed it.


Yes and it certainly wouldn't have continued if it was left to News 24.

Liquid News was a great programme but in hindsight it's very obvious why it had to go, BBC3 was very heavily criticised for being too celebrity based - which it was at the time. Not good for a PSB channel with the remit that Three does.

The current format of the BBC Three news is a far adequate replacement , it has retained that Liquid News attitude
GE
thegeek Founding member
Inspector Sands posted:
The current format of the BBC Three news is a far adequate replacement , it has retained that Liquid News attitude
But still not quite as good as it was at the beginning of the year, if you ask me: it had the right attitude, and the right news agenda. It's a bit too 'news-lite' these days for my liking. Still a good show, mind.

Right, I guess I'd better find my 'Save BBC 3 News' wristband and wander up and down outside TV Centre with it.
NE
Neil__
DJGM posted:
And with any luck, he'll take those boring orange blobs with him!


*gasp*

Still one of the best set of idents currently around, in my opinion.

Newer posts