TV Home Forum

Strictly Come Dancing | 2019

Rylan Joins the Presenting Line-Up (April 2019)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
GM
Gary McEwan
Does Dancing with the Stars still use the American public as the '4th' judge?

No, three judges has always been the judges line up on the ABC version in the states.


I know it's always been three judges, but the public used to also vote and give their points along with the judges hence the '4th' judge.
BR
Brekkie
Unless it's changed in the last couple of years I thought Dancing with the Stars used a 50:50 split for the voting, although I think combined them differently to Strictly.

So many of these 50:50 shows don't actually explain how the votes are combined (on screen at least), but my understanding is Strictly use a ranking system, with the rankings combined to give the final score (and I think usually the public vote breaking any tie) whilse Dancing with the Stars combined percentages - so the judges scores for all contestants added together and the couples judges score effectively became a percentage of the overall judges scores, which is then added to the percentage of votes they get.

24 days later

RO
rob Founding member
Jamie Laing has pulled out due to injury.

https://www.itv.com/news/2019-09-05/made-in-chelsea-star-jamie-laing-forced-to-pull-out-of-strictly-due-to-injury/
JK
JKDerry
Will there be a replacement or will they just continue with the 14 others?
NG
noggin Founding member
Will there be a replacement or will they just continue with the 14 others?


As it's at the very beginning of the run - there is the potential to recast without putting the replacement at too much of a disadvantage - so I think it could be a possibility IF they have people on standby.
NG
noggin Founding member
Does Dancing with the Stars still use the American public as the '4th' judge?

No, three judges has always been the judges line up on the ABC version in the states.


I know it's always been three judges, but the public used to also vote and give their points along with the judges hence the '4th' judge.


I think the '4th judge' was more a turn of phrase suggesting that the public were important judges too, rather than suggesting that the public only had 25% of the final say.
NG
noggin Founding member
Unless it's changed in the last couple of years I thought Dancing with the Stars used a 50:50 split for the voting, although I think combined them differently to Strictly.

So many of these 50:50 shows don't actually explain how the votes are combined (on screen at least), but my understanding is Strictly use a ranking system, with the rankings combined to give the final score (and I think usually the public vote breaking any tie) whilse Dancing with the Stars combined percentages - so the judges scores for all contestants added together and the couples judges score effectively became a percentage of the overall judges scores, which is then added to the percentage of votes they get.


Yep - Strictly uses a dual ranking system, no weighting of the public vote based on vote volume (just rank)
JK
JKDerry
Strictly launch show pulled in 7.8 million viewers overnight on BBC One peaking at 8.3 million, this was slightly down on the 2018 launch show which pulled in 8.1 million and peaked at 8.5 million.

However the Strictly launch show did beat BGT on ITV, which managed to attract 4.9 million viewers last night, peaking at 5.6 million.
PE
peterh
Did they announce kelvin fletcher as replacement on bbc breakfast or was I dreaming
DM
DeMarkay
Did they announce kelvin fletcher as replacement on bbc breakfast or was I dreaming


Yes.
JK
JKDerry
Did they announce kelvin fletcher as replacement on bbc breakfast or was I dreaming

Kelvin was confirmed on the BBC Strictly Twitter account yes
JA
JAS84
Andy Sugden from Emmerdale? Why wasn't he there in the first place, he's a bigger name than some of the so-called stars they had in the lineup already.

Newer posts