TV Home Forum

Strange sound error on empire strikes back

(November 2009)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
ST
stevek2
last night whilst watching empire strikes back, towards the end, there was a loss of sound but only the dialogue, all the other sound effects and music were there, just no actually voices. any ideas how that can happen
WH
Whataday Founding member
One of the sound channels were off I guess. It happens when I play certain DVDs on my faulty player.
MA
Markymark
last night whilst watching empire strikes back, towards the end, there was a loss of sound but only the dialogue, all the other sound effects and music were there, just no actually voices. any ideas how that can happen


A messed up downmix from the 5.1 sound track. In fact did the ITV HD screening have 5.1 sound ?
BS
Ben Shatliff
There seemed to be a few new shots in that version of The Empire Strikes Back. I got the new DVD release in 2004 which had updates, this seemed to have more.

Does anybody know if there is a never version on DVD with more effects than the one released in 2004?
BR
Brekkie
Kind of related, but kind of not, I've noticed in a few shows in the last couple of weeks the sound of the gallery leaking into the main programme, most recently with The X Factor last night.
ST
stevek2
thanks for that, would have thought all the audio would be on one track, not seperate

there are new scenes, the wompa eating the tauntaun being the main one
BC
Blake Connolly Founding member
There seemed to be a few new shots in that version of The Empire Strikes Back. I got the new DVD release in 2004 which had updates, this seemed to have more.

Does anybody know if there is a never version on DVD with more effects than the one released in 2004?


There's a full list of changes here, but it looks like the last biggest changes were in the 2004 DVDs where they changed some of the cast to match the prequels - Ian McDiarmid as the Emperor and Temuera Morrison as Boba Fett.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_changes_in_Star_Wars_re-releases
WW
WW Update
thanks for that, would have thought all the audio would be on one track, not seperate


It wouldn't be possible -- or at least practical -- to dub movies into other languages if that were the case (which would, in my not-so-humble opinion, be a good thing, but that's an argument for another day).

Newer posts