GE
I can't really see past Darren Clarke. He has already publicly said that he doesn't want to win the award on a sympathy vote, but the 'personality' he showed at the Ryder Cup gives him the credibility he deserves IMO.
Aside from Clarke, its a wide open playing field this year - no one contender really stands out on purely sporting merit.
It'll be interesting to see how this evening's live show pans out. The famously cringeworthy Lineker/Barker partnership from last year had better have improved to cope with an audience of 3,000! I'm also hoping the Beeb doesnt completely ditch the traditional music and features, etc, in favour of an all-singing, all-dancing stage show!
Btw, I mentioned in the BBC Sport thread about the absence of John Inverdale on the TV show tonight; it seems that he is hosting a simultaneous live broadcast from the NEC on Radio 5 Live, which is a slight consolation!
Aside from Clarke, its a wide open playing field this year - no one contender really stands out on purely sporting merit.
It'll be interesting to see how this evening's live show pans out. The famously cringeworthy Lineker/Barker partnership from last year had better have improved to cope with an audience of 3,000! I'm also hoping the Beeb doesnt completely ditch the traditional music and features, etc, in favour of an all-singing, all-dancing stage show!
Btw, I mentioned in the BBC Sport thread about the absence of John Inverdale on the TV show tonight; it seems that he is hosting a simultaneous live broadcast from the NEC on Radio 5 Live, which is a slight consolation!
SE
Square Eyes
Founding member
I think the list just demonstrates the dearth of sporting talent there has been this year, and in the year of the World Cup, not a single footballer in the list (or Rugby player for that matter).
Also, why is the show starting at 7pm ? Isn't it always traditionally at 8pm ?
Also, why is the show starting at 7pm ? Isn't it always traditionally at 8pm ?
BR
It does seem for the big events that John Inverdale becomes the top man at Radio 5 Live - though apart from Any Sporting Questions I don't think he does much else for them!
MI
Just my opinion but:
Zara Phillips wouldn't be on the list if she wasn't royal.
Darren Clarke wouldn't be on the list if his wife hadn't have died - other British players won three matches in the Ryder Cup.
Ricky Hatton and Joe Calzaghe should both be in the top 3, as they are bona-fide world champions. Calzaghe especially took on the best fighter in his division America had to offer and almost murdered him.
Panesar... it's the Jonny Wilkinson complex all over again - English people relying on one man to play a team sport.
Nicole Cooke: Won't win because she's a cyclist and sadly no matter how many Tour de Frances she wins no-one will care.
Button.... don't waste my time.
Phil Taylor: dominates the PDC. Yes THAT branch of darts ... a bunch of BDO has-beens and mediocre talent.
Zara Phillips wouldn't be on the list if she wasn't royal.
Darren Clarke wouldn't be on the list if his wife hadn't have died - other British players won three matches in the Ryder Cup.
Ricky Hatton and Joe Calzaghe should both be in the top 3, as they are bona-fide world champions. Calzaghe especially took on the best fighter in his division America had to offer and almost murdered him.
Panesar... it's the Jonny Wilkinson complex all over again - English people relying on one man to play a team sport.
Nicole Cooke: Won't win because she's a cyclist and sadly no matter how many Tour de Frances she wins no-one will care.
Button.... don't waste my time.
Phil Taylor: dominates the PDC. Yes THAT branch of darts ... a bunch of BDO has-beens and mediocre talent.
WI
william
Founding member
Personally I rather wish they still called it 'Sports Review of the Year' rather than 'Sports Personality' - though I think the 7pm-9 slot is more sensible (even if only caused by having to slot in the final episode of Planet Earth).
This show has, I think, received the most publicity in terms of cross-network trails that I can ever remember.
This show has, I think, received the most publicity in terms of cross-network trails that I can ever remember.
WI
Yes, much more fun to listen to that with the TV sound turned down (and not his first work of the day, he did the final of the tennis at the RAH earlier..)
william
Founding member
bbcsport posted:
Btw, I mentioned in the BBC Sport thread about the absence of John Inverdale on the TV show tonight; it seems that he is hosting a simultaneous live broadcast from the NEC on Radio 5 Live, which is a slight consolation!
Yes, much more fun to listen to that with the TV sound turned down (and not his first work of the day, he did the final of the tennis at the RAH earlier..)
BM
Theo Walcott is Youngs Sports Personality????? What is this world coming to? So, he's now been involved in 2 dodgy selections....we await the 3rd.
Someone pass me the baseball bat.
Someone pass me the baseball bat.