PT
The 17 yr old, Bryrony (sp?). She had a good voice but lacked personality. She seemed very funny though.
AD
The upmarket factor is hardly copying - when was Pop Idol ever upmarket?!
However, BBC, ITV, whatever channel it is on, I didn't watch, and don't plan to.
Andrew posted:
Despite it just being upmarket Pop Idol, and therefore completely copycat, I'm sure it'll be a ratings winner with the BBC1 audience
Although, why they had to give the gig to Graham Norton, yet again, I don't know
Although, why they had to give the gig to Graham Norton, yet again, I don't know
The upmarket factor is hardly copying - when was Pop Idol ever upmarket?!
However, BBC, ITV, whatever channel it is on, I didn't watch, and don't plan to.
JE
The upmarket factor is hardly copying - when was Pop Idol ever upmarket?!
However, BBC, ITV, whatever channel it is on, I didn't watch, and don't plan to.
BBC of course! I very much doubt Andrew would have slagged it off had it been on ITV1
I didnt watch but it sounds like a crap format for Saturday night entertainment. Both the BBC and ITV are as bad as each other when it comes to Saturday night tv at the moment, the BBC was better earlier this year because of Doctor Who.
Jez
Founding member
Adam posted:
Andrew posted:
Despite it just being upmarket Pop Idol, and therefore completely copycat, I'm sure it'll be a ratings winner with the BBC1 audience
Although, why they had to give the gig to Graham Norton, yet again, I don't know
Although, why they had to give the gig to Graham Norton, yet again, I don't know
The upmarket factor is hardly copying - when was Pop Idol ever upmarket?!
However, BBC, ITV, whatever channel it is on, I didn't watch, and don't plan to.
BBC of course! I very much doubt Andrew would have slagged it off had it been on ITV1
I didnt watch but it sounds like a crap format for Saturday night entertainment. Both the BBC and ITV are as bad as each other when it comes to Saturday night tv at the moment, the BBC was better earlier this year because of Doctor Who.
:-(
A former member
Ah correction
Good repeats
there a difference!
Good repeats
there a difference!
BR
Why the **** are they making a full series out of this ****?
It's niche at best - and while a talent search like this might warrant a one-off documentary, it's not doing the BBC any favours being on Saturday nights week after week!
ITV deservedly take some flack, but BBC on Saturday's isn't any better.
When does Robin Hood start - saw a brief bumper style promo a couple of weeks ago but nothing since!
It's niche at best - and while a talent search like this might warrant a one-off documentary, it's not doing the BBC any favours being on Saturday nights week after week!
ITV deservedly take some flack, but BBC on Saturday's isn't any better.
When does Robin Hood start - saw a brief bumper style promo a couple of weeks ago but nothing since!
JV
James Vertigan
Founding member
They should've renamed this programme tonight... "How do you solve a problem like having the two most irritating men in television on back to back?"
Fortunately it's easy for me - I live in a multi-channel home!
Fortunately it's easy for me - I live in a multi-channel home!