TM
The pitchside pundits are really pointless and add very little to the coverage, ITV did this for some of the World Cup games as well.. We only see them for 1 minute and they're gone..
As the first week has finished here is BBC & ITV plans for next weekend coverage
6 Nations Championship Week 2
Saturday 13th February 2016 – Live on BBC Sport
France v Ireland
Presenter: Gabby Logan
With: Thomas Castaignede, Keith Wood & Paul O’Connell
Commentators: Eddie Butler & Brian Moore
Wales v Scotland
Presenter: John Inverdale
With: Jeremy Guscott, Martyn Williams & Andy Nicol
Commentators: Andrew Cotter, Jonathan Davies & Chris Paterson
Sunday 14th February 2016 – Live on ITV Sport
Italy v England
Presenter: Mark Pougatch
With: Jonny Wilkinson, Sir Clive Woodward & Maggie Alphonsi
Commentators: Nick Mullins, Ben Kay & David Flatman
Pitchside: Martin Bayfield, Ugo Monye & Marco Bortolami
Seems now that Philip Matthews is no longer a part of BBC Sport coverage with former Ireland captain Paul O'Connell taking his place and wouldn't be surprised to see Keith Wood join the commentary which he has done on Irish Radio in the past. Meanwhile good to see the excellent David Flatman is involved in the co-commentary for ITV Sport but seems to be an awful lot of pundits involved for an Italy v England match.
6 Nations Championship Week 2
Saturday 13th February 2016 – Live on BBC Sport
France v Ireland
Presenter: Gabby Logan
With: Thomas Castaignede, Keith Wood & Paul O’Connell
Commentators: Eddie Butler & Brian Moore
Wales v Scotland
Presenter: John Inverdale
With: Jeremy Guscott, Martyn Williams & Andy Nicol
Commentators: Andrew Cotter, Jonathan Davies & Chris Paterson
Sunday 14th February 2016 – Live on ITV Sport
Italy v England
Presenter: Mark Pougatch
With: Jonny Wilkinson, Sir Clive Woodward & Maggie Alphonsi
Commentators: Nick Mullins, Ben Kay & David Flatman
Pitchside: Martin Bayfield, Ugo Monye & Marco Bortolami
Seems now that Philip Matthews is no longer a part of BBC Sport coverage with former Ireland captain Paul O'Connell taking his place and wouldn't be surprised to see Keith Wood join the commentary which he has done on Irish Radio in the past. Meanwhile good to see the excellent David Flatman is involved in the co-commentary for ITV Sport but seems to be an awful lot of pundits involved for an Italy v England match.
The pitchside pundits are really pointless and add very little to the coverage, ITV did this for some of the World Cup games as well.. We only see them for 1 minute and they're gone..
Last edited by TMD_24 on 7 February 2016 7:13pm
TL
Toby Lerone
The pitchside pundits are really pointless and add very little to the coverage, ITV did this for some of the World Cup games as well.. We only see them for 1 minute and they're gone..
Usually they use the co-commentators and the BBC do exactly the same. Next weeks coverage though is clearly missing a neutral voice in either commentary or the studio.
10 people on the one match seems a bit much, they should promote Marco Bortolami to the studio and get rid of the pitchside element as a 2nd set of studio pundits. They can have Bayfield or Gabriel Clarke talking to the commentators or some guests they find but not when they already have a studio, ITV should be reminded it is only Italy v England not New Zealand v Australia in the World Cup Final so their coverage is feeling over crowded at the moment.
Just to finish talk on this weekend coverage Rugby Special was on BBC Two at 7pm and had John Inverdale presenting from Salford with Keith Wood, Martyn Williams and Jeremy Guscott. The titles remained the same as live coverage but the old Rugby Special music was played over the coming up section of the show. The BBC commentary of Ireland v Wales was provided by Eddie Butler and former Ireland Scrum Half Tomas O'Leary.
RO
Having heard the commentary yesterday, Nick mullins did say the "Irish television company have chosen so and so as man of the match" after the graphic came up on screen, which suggests RTE did host broadcast this game. On that basis, I'd think BBC and ITV will host broadcast their own games, but using the unified graphics package.
Otherwise, Nick Mullins would've said the man of the match at the same time the graphic came up, or just before.
Otherwise, Nick Mullins would've said the man of the match at the same time the graphic came up, or just before.
RS
Rob_Schneider
In the event of Wales, Scotland, England or Ireland playing one another, do the nations have their own, more partisan, coverage?
TL
Toby Lerone
Well that's an event that occures a lot in the Six Nations.
Wales used to have their own coverage but haven't for a number of years, although Scrum V airs instead of Rugby Special on Sundays.
Wales used to have their own coverage but haven't for a number of years, although Scrum V airs instead of Rugby Special on Sundays.
BBC NI also used to do their own thing for Ireland matches both in 6 Nations and Autumn Internationals. For the Autumn matches they would have their own studio with punditry and commentators but in the 6 Nations they would use the national BBC coverage with Inverdale etc. but use BBC NI commentary, so instead of Eddie Butler and Brian Moore we would have Jim Neilly and someone like David Humphreys or Tyrone Howe but the last time they did their own opt-out commentary it was at Croke Park and Ireland haven't played there since 2010 and UTV haven't done any coverage in fact hardly any sport since they did their own coverage of the 2007 Rugby World Cup.
:-(
A former member
We do have a Pancake Day sting. looks just like last year.

