TV Home Forum

Saturday Night Takeaway 2017

(February 2017)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
SW
Steve Williams
They managed it in the early days of SNT. Everything felt far more natural and fun. Whereas tonight, the second Ant said he had big news, I knew it was a set up for a joke or lead in to something.


I think that's looking back at the early series with rose-tinted glasses a bit, of course it was going to be a set-up for a joke. You can't expect subtlety on this series. There were loads of bits on the early series that were contrived and stagey too, probably more so than now.

Both of those games are ones I played versions of as a child. There are far more original game ideas on YouTube.


And the other thing as well is that, regardless if they're on YouTube (and as you say, Make Em Laugh especially is hardly a concept), on YouTube Ant and Dec aren't playing them. We're watching this for Ant and Dec, not the format.

Anyway, last night we had Kevin Whateley dressed as Geoff from Byker Grove and not being introduced and named, and last week they were able to chuck away a reunion with a soldier returning from Afghanistan in thirty seconds. It's a remarkable series. I would also suggest it is the best thing on TV right now.
bilky asko, buster and DCI02 gave kudos
SP
Steve in Pudsey
The aforementioned What's Next problem:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8WvavJhEdMc

Standing in front of a curtain... Is that a deliberate nod to M&W and the comparisons?
LL
Larry the Loafer
It's argued that curtains did in fact pre-date Morecambe and Wise by at least a couple of years.
SP
Steve in Pudsey
But are considered an M&W trademark.
WH
Whataday Founding member
I don't think it's so much about what's M&W and what's not. It's more them trying to emulate a music hall comedy double act, when they are not. I don't think it's why people find them endearing, and it feels rather forced.
:-(
A former member
This has been a far better series, its been a bit more off the wall, I like a few weeks ago how Mrs brown went off script and this evening with that phone competition has been enjoyable.
:-(
A former member
This has been a far better series, its been a bit more off the wall, I like it a few weeks ago, how Mrs brown went off script and this evening with that phone competition has been enjoyable.
Last edited by A former member on 25 March 2017 9:09pm

14 days later

AN
Andrew Founding member
Cat Deeley revealed as Mask Face, I don't think many expected that. It wasn't Cowell, or Walliams or any of the predictable suggestions.

I wonder what all the Americans will think if they are in the Magic Kingdom today, and wonder what is going on.

They will recognise Cat though, although how famous is Cat in the U.S compared to her equivalent here?
Last edited by Andrew on 8 April 2017 8:23pm
:-(
A former member
She is well know, she is the presenter of So You Think You Can Dance
:-(
A former member
It felt like six weeks of promos for and one final hour-and-a-half advert for Disney World. Not the future of tv I look forward to.
TV
TVMan
Slightly stretched credits overlayed on the show at the end, suppose it's better than last year, with an expensive fireworks display taking place over the regular black credit background
UB
UBox
I noticed the end credits were shown over a live feed. If I remember correctly this goes against ITV policy to have boring black background?

Newer posts