It's still not "another incarnation" of the same show. Just like CBBC's Saturday Show was in no way connected to Central's 1980s Saturday Show, even though they were both Saturday morning kid's magazine shows.
A show that has the same name, timeslot and format it is, a "relaunch" of a previous show it isn't.
Well said. There was also TSW's region-only The Saturday Show, which was the first, and they renamed that to Freeze Frame once Central came up with their networked effort that used the name. Different shows, entirely.
For a great example of TV formats with the same name, consider 'The Tube'...
Am I referring to the famous live pop music magazine show that Tyne Tees made for Channel Four in the early 80s?
Am I referring to Carlton's series about life on the London Underground?
Am I referring to the BBC Two documentary series about how the London Underground is coping with a massive growth in usage?
So, no, Channel 5's Saturday Show doesn't belong here. It's not aimed at kids, it's just more bland 'Saturday Kitchen' style guff from a broadcaster that trawls through the skips of other channels for ideas.