TV Home Forum

Revised BBC End Credit Promotions

From Nov 21 (November 2008)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
CY
cylon6
I think that I spotted a new style credit squeeze after Diagnosis Murder. Instead of the credits being squeezed into a little box on the bottom right, it took up the bottom half of the screen.

http://i113.photobucket.com/albums/n211/cylon1_2006/21112008389.jpg
DB
dbl
I knew they were gonna go that route, a lot better IMO.
CY
cylon6
dbl posted:
I knew they were gonna go that route, a lot better IMO.


Isn't it though? Very Happy

It chopped off the top and bottom of credits on programmes like Diagnosis Murder that aren't following the BBC credit rules.
DB
dbl
cylon6 posted:
dbl posted:
I knew they were gonna go that route, a lot better IMO.


Isn't it though? Very Happy

It chopped off the top and bottom of credits on programmes like Diagnosis Murder that aren't following the BBC credit rules.

Hmm.. thats a point, maybe good for scrolling but not so good for 'caption' style credits.
EDIT, Video: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6y4sJmRae5Q
CH
chris
dbl posted:
cylon6 posted:
dbl posted:
I knew they were gonna go that route, a lot better IMO.


Isn't it though? Very Happy

It chopped off the top and bottom of credits on programmes like Diagnosis Murder that aren't following the BBC credit rules.

Hmm.. thats a point, maybe good for scrolling but not so good for 'caption' style credits.
EDIT, Video: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6y4sJmRae5Q


It also doesn't animate as nice as the other. Also noticed the return of Gill Sans - the previous used swiss. I think it looked better when the logo was outside the "big coloured box", the "big coloured box" doesn't seem to line up either, and why have they ditched the picture of the ident in the background? That was a nice feature.

Does anyone else think they're being petty and purpously making this one look inferior so they can make a point?
JO
Jonny
They should just admit defeat and return to a more traditional ECP style.

ITV1 has got it spot on with their current (non-soaps) ECP. I know people moan about the plain black credits but their ECP's animation and design is superior to any other channel at present.

The BBC's new design looks half-baked. They've had plenty of time since the announcement of these modifications to come up with something better than that.
AS
Asa Admin
(Split topic from the BBC One thread)

Hmmm..well they were worth waiting for, weren't they? Rolling Eyes

Can't argue with the fact they're more legible but it'll be rubbish with 4:3 programmes. The screens seem to get 'taller' whilst it's being shrunk into the bottom box, along with still having the obligatory frame jump.

And what's with the static coloured background and iPlayer/Web2.0 fading black and font looking just a bit too big?

Here's the one after EE. A work of art:

http://tvfi.co.uk/ecp_20081121_0828(1).jpg
AG
AxG
http://i51.photobucket.com/albums/f363/TheAxG/BBCOneEastEnders211108.png?t=1227299523
Here's a clearer image, showing the 'if you have been affected with..."

Edit: Damn photobucket.com it's too complicated! Smile
CY
cylon6
As mentioned, these are rubbish with 4:3 programmes as today's Diagnosis Murder proved. Rolling Eyes

The most annoying thing is that the BBC still have the credit rules in place so we can't go back to having jokes or funny scenes played over the credits. BOO!!
BR
Brekkie
When these launched I said the credits should take up the full bottom third of the screen - that menu thing was useless anyway.

However, the BBC being the BBC means yet again they bodge it up and it won't be until shows adapt their style once again that they'll begin to work. I imagine these would work better for shows like Doctor Who which have the character and actor on the same line - but only if the ECP involves cropping the centre of the screen to fit the box, rather than squeezing it down.
MA
Malpass
The "faded ident" in the box looked classy, but without it, it looks like it was made in 5 minutes.
JO
Jonny
It will come as no surprise that BBC Three's effort is just as garish:

http://s176.photobucket.com/albums/w191/2007TopGearDog/BBC3ECPnew.flv

The layout is a huge improvement but the design is appalling.

Newer posts