TV Home Forum

The Paul O'Grady Show Returns - 23 February 2009

(February 2009)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
SO
southwestman
Can anyone answer this question for me, why after a few years does a show become old news, 'had it' and need to be replaced? Programmes like the Paul Ogrady show in America run for years and years without being taken off the air.. look at Live with Regis and Kelly, The View or even the late night chat shows. They have been on air for years, but in the UK, a show has 5-10 years under its belt and then seen as old and needs pullings from the schedule. Why? do the British become bored quicker? or do we always need change?
PT
Put The Telly On
southwestman posted:
Can anyone answer this question for me, why after a few years does a show become old news, 'had it' and need to be replaced? Programmes like the Paul Ogrady show in America run for years and years without being taken off the air.. look at Live with Regis and Kelly, The View or even the late night chat shows. They have been on air for years, but in the UK, a show has 5-10 years under its belt and then seen as old and needs pullings from the schedule. Why? do the British become bored quicker? or do we always need change?


I think it's because our humour has different limits.
BR
Brekkie
The only prime-time slot I could see C4 giving him is something like 8pm on Sundays. It's a bit tricky now giving him a later slot as he's not hip enough to tick the trendy box, and if he goes too adult he risks alienating his older fanbase.
PT
Put The Telly On
Brekkie posted:
The only prime-time slot I could see C4 giving him is something like 8pm on Sundays.


Well then there would be no point moving his 5pm show in that case.
RM
Roger Mellie
Gavin Scott posted:
The show is a bit tired for my liking.

I think they should get Richard & Judy back.


Current newspaper tittle-tattle has it, that Judy wishes to quit broadcasting and Richard to go solo from now on.

Assuming that's true, maybe Channel 4 could entice Mr Madeley back for his own chat-show-- or find him another on-screen 'wife' (probably Mylene Klass, just for a change Wink).

It is possible that Des & Mel could return with their own show on C4, their brief reunion (covering for POG) seemed to be well-received.
GS
Gavin Scott Founding member
Roger Mellie posted:
Gavin Scott posted:
The show is a bit tired for my liking.

I think they should get Richard & Judy back.


Current newspaper tittle-tattle has it, that Judy wishes to quit broadcasting and Richard to go solo from now on.

Assuming that's true, maybe Channel 4 could entice Mr Madeley back for his own chat-show-- or find him another on-screen 'wife' (probably Mylene Klass, just for a change Wink).



Oh. That is interesting.

Something along the years changed with regard to my opinion of Richard. I used to find him unbearably smug and overbearing, but now I really, really like him as a presenter. Its possible it has something to do with the fact that he's aged into an handsome man.

Not sure how he would be flying solo - but I'd tune in to find out.
BR
Brekkie
nok32uk posted:
Brekkie posted:
The only prime-time slot I could see C4 giving him is something like 8pm on Sundays.


Well then there would be no point moving his 5pm show in that case.

He's not going to rate any better in prime-time on C4 than he does at 5pm - the only benefit of course is just doing one show a week rather than five.
AN
Andrew Founding member
The show could be much better but hasn't had a new idea in years, when the Organ Game was axed they just extended the other features and brought in more annoying kids and padded with those in and out of break promotions that they air over and over again.

Although I still enjoy the show, since he moved to Channel 4 you can count his other TV appearances on half of one hand. Maybe if he stopped doing his chat show he could use his talents on a range of new formats
BR
Brekkie
The trouble with Paul O'Grady and indeed any other show which uses similar features is that when you have a "family" of regulars for features it becomes very exclusive - the regular viewers may appreciate it, but to a certain extent it excludes the casual viewers.
DA
David_02
Is Barbara Windsor the first guest?
TO
TODAY
I really enjoyed his show when it was on ITV, but when he moved to Channel 4 I felt he was trying too hard to make the show better than before but instead he made it worse.

There isn't enough variety now, it's basically the same show each day whereas a few years ago he could do much more comedy sketches and it was all round a lot more entertaining.

Can someone clear this up for me?
Am I right in saying that ITV offered Paul a late night chat show as a replacement for Parkinson last year but he declined it?
:-(
A former member
I believe that was sky!

Newer posts