TV Home Forum

BBC Oneness - idents and presentation

"Watch this space" as BBC Creative respond to ident change request (December 2016)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
IS
Inspector Sands
Jake posted:
Perhaps it'll just be a year long experiment.

Apparently so, it's a year long collaboration according to the Daily Mail:
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-4080244/BBC1-viewers-left-disappointed-broadcaster-s-dull-random-new-idents-unveiled-today.html
:-(
A former member
This is surreal or comedy gold.


Jake posted:
Perhaps it'll just be a year long experiment.

Apparently so, it's a year long collaboration according to the Daily Mail:
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-4080244/BBC1-viewers-left-disappointed-broadcaster-s-dull-random-new-idents-unveiled-today.html
GI
ginnyfan
This is actually insulting to viewers. Who wants to see manboobs and geezers taking a bath during lunchtime or at any time of day.

How could anyone allow these to go on air for a channel that used to set the standard for the rest of the world, is beyond me???

Plus the terrible Oneness line. WTF?
orange, Custard56 and harshy gave kudos
RD
RDJ
Currently there's uproar as tonight's edition of Eastenders announced an alternative ending on the BBC One Snapchat page.

Well an hour on and there is still nothing posted... other than a dodgy image of the Pre-2006 BBC One logo and music from the now-finished Bauble ident.

It's causing outrage on Twitter... I think they need to re-hire their person running Snapchat.
JA
james-2001
The person running their snapchat is probably the same person who signed off these new idents.
BR
Brekkie
RDJ posted:
It's causing outrage on Twitter... I think they need to re-hire their person running Snapchat.

I think they need to worry less about Snapchat and the like and more abuot what they're broadcasting on their actual television channel.
BB
BBCME Founding member
My thoughts echo everyone else who has posted before me - bland, boring and don't represent the channel.

If there has only been a handful made I'm hoping they stop production and get pulled. Some sort of emergency meeting at the BBC when everyone is back on Wednesday.

Even Tony Hall must have wondered WTF was happening with those swimmers before Sherlock.
LO
lobster
they are dire.

do the bbc even have a head of presentation?
DJ
DJ Dave
msim posted:
These, and in particular the beach 'swimmers', have an ITV1 2006 feel to them. Remember that horrendous ident (called Pride or something*) that was used far too often where you had the obese man pushing out his hairy stomach and the child running his tongue over a tooth? Well here we now have something far worse with a load of saggy bodies standing around and jiggling fat arses leading us in to the nation's leading TV news bulletins...

*It was actually two separate ones, Pride and Love

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fD7qM3ii_ug
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ca4urM0eii0



Come on even these Itv Idents are better then this lot, they wouldn't be so bad if they had been better shot, had something red in them and a catchy theme tune.
IS
Inspector Sands
This is surreal or comedy gold.

Not sure about either really. Though as a year long project it does make a bit more sense.


The big problem though is that sort of thing only works when the audience knows that. Years ago BBC London had the idea of exhibiting art in their newsroom behind their studio area - starting with a big wire hand. This was explained on the first day but for everyone else it just looked like an odd random object. It was a nice idea and the thing itself was nice, but it just didn't work
GL
Gluben
Jake posted:
Perhaps it'll just be a year long experiment.

Apparently so, it's a year long collaboration according to the Daily Mail:
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-4080244/BBC1-viewers-left-disappointed-broadcaster-s-dull-random-new-idents-unveiled-today.html


Great, my tweet is part of their headline. Thanks for not asking, Daily Mail.
MS
msim



Come on even these Itv Idents are better then this lot, they wouldn't be so bad if they had been better shot, had something red in them and a catchy theme tune.


I didn't say they're weren't better. The point I was making was that people on here and elsewhere commented frequently they were sick of seeing that bloke's stomach and that child's tooth. They were off putting and cringe inducing. Now we have the BBC shoving Mavis and Bill's saggy body parts at us at every junction which is going to annoy very quickly.

Newer posts