« Topics
1234...223224225226...402403404
Andrew Wood3,649 posts since 30 Mar 2001
Central (West) Midlands Today
Just when you think the idents couldn't get worse. An absolute embarrassment.


I can't share your opinion. It was just a playful departure from the norm, and I'm glad NW and NI done it.


I very much agree with Darren.

Brekkie, did you have the same sentiment in 2014 ( https://theident.gallery/player.php?id=BBC1-2014-ID-CAPES-DOCTORWHO-1 ) and 2013 ( https://theident.gallery/player.php?id=BBC1-2013-ID-DOCTORWHO-1 + others)?
5
denton, MMcG198 and FBC gave kudos
MMcG198632 posts since 14 Dec 2014
UTV Newsline
Just when you think the idents couldn't get worse. An absolute embarrassment.


An embarrassment? How so?

The "idents" themselves are certainly an embarrassment and are beyond talking about at this stage. However, Duncan's link (and NI's take on it) - in my opinion - was nicely executed. There's always a danger that announcers go overboard and try too hard to be funny/creative. And for the most part - I'm thinking of some of the clowns on the Channel 4 and UKTV channels - it falls flat and is just utterly cringeworthy.

Duncan got this spot on IMO. And the brief glimpse of the 'BBC2 COLOUR' testcard was a nice nod to the anniversary of colour.

Very difficult to please everyone. But, I appreciated it.
4
mat76, denton and Andrew Wood gave kudos
Brekkie30,997 posts since 4 Jan 2003
HTV Wales Wales Today
Just when you think the idents couldn't get worse. An absolute embarrassment.


I can't share your opinion. It was just a playful departure from the norm, and I'm glad NW and NI done it.


I very much agree with Darren.

Brekkie, did you have the same sentiment in 2014 ( https://theident.gallery/player.php?id=BBC1-2014-ID-CAPES-DOCTORWHO-1 ) and 2013 ( https://theident.gallery/player.php?id=BBC1-2013-ID-DOCTORWHO-1 + others)?

They were done so much better. This was just poorly done IMO.
I preferred the internet when it had a sense of humour.
dbl9,144 posts since 11 Jun 2004
London London

There's always a danger that announcers go overboard and try too hard to be funny/creative. And for the most part - I'm thinking of some of the clowns on the Channel 4 and UKTV channels - it falls flat and is just utterly cringeworthy.

Ouch. I'm going to have to disagree there. Channel 4 has personality. But I didn't think the Doctor Who link was that bad, it's just a little bit of fun.

Last edited by dbl on 2 July 2017 12:48pm
1
watchingtv gave kudos
D.Page
For the benefit of those who have doubts as to whether the early ones have been shelved, Sea Swimmers (ver.2) was used on Network at 11am, leading into The Sunday Politics.
Wicko1,553 posts since 3 Dec 2003
Meridian (South) South Today
For the benefit of those who have doubts as to whether the early ones have been shelved, Sea Swimmers (ver.2) was used on Network at 11am, leading into The Sunday Politics.


Yikes! The man boobs have been taken back out of their box!
If we only get one life, why does it take several attempts to get it right?
623058
Why is England still using it? The nations all had nicer idents.

The swimmer remind me of this, hopeful this is the fall of the BBC one ident and next year we get the rise.
1
Spencer For Hire gave kudos
MMcG198632 posts since 14 Dec 2014
UTV Newsline
For the benefit of those who have doubts as to whether the early ones have been shelved, Sea Swimmers (ver.2) was used on Network at 11am, leading into The Sunday Politics.


'Sea Swimmers' has also put in the odd appearance on BBC One NI over the last few weeks. I've also spotted 'Exercise Class' on one occasion on BBC One NI recently.

I can't believe I'm even bothering to comment on screenings of this tripe.