TV Home Forum

BBC Oneness - idents and presentation

"Watch this space" as BBC Creative respond to ident change request (December 2016)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
PE
peterh
There was a thing at the start of the year saying that oneness was for one year and somewhere it says the BBC is completely being rebranded in 2018 complete with new font
:-(
A former member
Another Bog sting appeared.


:-(
A former member
So there give us "fit" half naked people? Does the BBC not understand, we dont want these types of stings,.


These were half decent...

DP
D.Page
Another Bog sting appeared.


It's the first Bog Snorkellers Giraffe sting (which I've added to the set on previous page), so all five have had their first sting aired. I'm kinda hoping they only have the one sting each, to be honest Very Happy
JO
John
East Midlands Today had a report (thurs 18:30) from a ten pin bowling alley in Nottingham showing the university's team fillming a new ident including an interview with the 'famous' photographer who directed them. Looks terrible complete with stereotypical student with blue hair.
JA
james-2001
I actually saw a book of Martin Parr's work today. He's a talented photogrpaher, but it's just not something that translates into video, and that's the real problem with these idents. It's basically as if you're filming a photoshoot. As I said before I don't really think you can massively blame him, he's only doing what he knows and what he's been asked to do. It's the other people behind the idea.
DP
D.Page
I actually saw a book of Martin Parr's work today. He's a talented photogrpaher, but it's just not something that translates into video, and that's the real problem with these idents. It's basically as if you're filming a photoshoot.


Agreed. I've said the same before.

As I said before I don't really think you can massively blame him, he's only doing what he knows and what he's been asked to do. It's the other people behind the idea.


He is there looking through the viewfinder with all these sequences, spending time practising the shoots and then finally filming them, so he is in a position to advise the people around him and those behind the idea that this is just not working. You may feel he is getting paid probably fairly handsomely for this gig and so may wish to keep quiet about any reservations he may have. However, he has a reputation to wish to keep in high regard. What is abundantly clear is that he isn't a cinematographer and because of this, he, perhaps, is not really able to provide any suggestions as to alternative ways to shoot. For that, you need to have the eye of a filmmaker.
DP
D.Page
Allotment Holders Sting #2:



Questionable focus pulling?
DE
denton
I actually saw a book of Martin Parr's work today. He's a talented photogrpaher, but it's just not something that translates into video, and that's the real problem with these idents. It's basically as if you're filming a photoshoot.


Agreed. I've said the same before.

As I said before I don't really think you can massively blame him, he's only doing what he knows and what he's been asked to do. It's the other people behind the idea.


He is there looking through the viewfinder with all these sequences, spending time practising the shoots and then finally filming them, so he is in a position to advise the people around him and those behind the idea that this is just not working. You may feel he is getting paid probably fairly handsomely for this gig and so may wish to keep quiet about any reservations he may have. However, he has a reputation to wish to keep in high regard. What is abundantly clear is that he isn't a cinematographer and because of this, he, perhaps, is not really able to provide any suggestions as to alternative ways to shoot. For that, you need to have the eye of a filmmaker.


Martin Parr goes up a ladder and takes a still, shows it to the DoP, who briefs the camera operator, who then goes up the ladder to film the scene.
DP
D.Page
Martin Parr goes up a ladder and takes a still, shows it to the DoP, who briefs the camera operator, who then goes up the ladder to film the scene.


The ladder in question. God, that appears so sloppy.

*
CU
Custard56
I have no idea what the rationale was behind the bog snorkellers ident - quaint, quirky country charm? - but it's possibly the worst excuse for an "ident" I've ever seen. It's like BBC One has been taken over by the Monster Raving Loony Party.
DP
D.Page
Boxers #2 Sting:

Newer posts