TV Home Forum

BBC Oneness - idents and presentation

"Watch this space" as BBC Creative respond to ident change request (December 2016)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
:-(
A former member
...It's been bugging me for years and I've not found a suitable work around.

There is one obvious workaround

Well indeed, and I have used it in various places before - even cutting and pasting parts of videos to get a complete piece when recordings have ballsed-up. cf the latest BBC Parliament filler!

As for the channels it occurs on, it's usually only on BBC ONE and TWO Wink
PC
p_c_u_k
No bleach, just no reticence to admit when my opinion has changed.

Look, I am an old-fashioned idents person, otherwise I wouldn't be hanging around here. But there's no point in me keeping up a pretence of outrage when I'm beginning to see the point. Are they classics? God no.
DP
D.Page
...It's been bugging me for years and I've not found a suitable work around.

There is one obvious workaround

Well indeed, and I have used it in various places before - even cutting and pasting parts of videos to get a complete piece when recordings have ballsed-up. cf the latest BBC Parliament filler!

As for the channels it occurs on, it's usually only on BBC ONE and TWO Wink


It's called Sod's law!
GO
gonzo
They've just grown on me, they're a bit gash, but there's an awkwardness about them I just like.
IS
Inspector Sands
Yeah, now there are a few and the context has been established they work a bit better. I don't mind them as much now

They just lack any excitement or pizzazz though
DB
dbl
Not sure if anyone has heard of this book called 'The TV Brand Builders' but it's an excellent book which talks about the how marketing has ingrained into TV presentation and content, it touches on the production and pitching of the circle idents and Peter Fincham's (and team) amused reaction to viewers making spoof versions of the 2006 rebrand. The relationship between top level management and branding, as well as ITV's 2013 rebrand to save an ailing brand.

https://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B01DMAKIAG/ref=dp-kindle-redirect?_encoding=UTF8&btkr=1
Last edited by dbl on 12 February 2017 7:16pm - 2 times in total
BE
Bert75
The new BBC 1 look will never grow on me
JC
JCB
Not presentation related but a topic that get's TV Forum equally riled up....Comic Relief & how rubbish it is these days. Well it seems the BBC has taken note and decided "to actually make it funny this year" with a "reboot" via these two...



Lenny Henry & Richard Curtis launched this years campaign a coupe of weeks ago agreeing with the common argument that the telethon has become too slick over the past decade. They promised this years show would be going back to it's "anarchic" roots with comedians rather than presenters anchoring and much more live stuff in the studio.

Considering the watering down of the show has never affected donations it's a bold move to shake things up like this so credit to them for trying something different rather than playing safe again.
orange, Jeffmister and London Lite gave kudos
IS
Inspector Sands
Though it's not a studio, it's coming from one of the smaller arenas at the 02. They also announced Comic Relief events on the night at comedy clubs around the country, but Im not sure if they'll end up on the telly on the night


Hopefully it'll have a good atmosphere. The last one at the Palladium was the best in a long while
Last edited by Inspector Sands on 15 February 2017 4:43pm
SC
scottishtv Founding member
The last one at the Palladium was the best in a long while

I agree, and for what it's worth, I appreciated the slick, professional approach taken by the production team.

EDIT: In fact, they said the same thing back in 2015 according to this thread.
LL
Larry the Loafer
Depends if we're actually going to get a live, anarchic show or just an extended Live at the Apollo. I agree it needs freshening up because the telethon itself is becoming almost identical to Children In Need. I'm not entirely sure locking everybody in a theatre was the right move, but it's nice to hear they're trying to loosen things up again.
JO
Joe
The inconsistent branding appears to get worse (unless this is a one-off dodgy version, or this is a small part of some incredible rebrand)...



Newer posts