TV Home Forum

New look Top Gear

with Chris Evans, Matt LeBlanc, et al . . . (May 2016)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
IS
Inspector Sands
Chris's presenting style in the studio links is starting to seem forced and unnaturally jolly, almost as if he's rubbing it in to somebody that he got the gig.

Yes, I like him as a presenter but he does feel a bit forced. His attitude with everything else he does is to 'be yourself' - i.e. a natural style of presenting. I'm sure it's just because it's the first, he'll settle down and fund the shows 'voice'
:-(
A former member
Here is Extra bit, One has to wonder if this was done to prop up the Online content for BBC3?
http://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/p03w1dcs/top-gear-extra-gear-episode-1
VM
VMPhil
Interesting to me anyway, that they've gone with the more American style static credits, rather than scrolling credits in the past.

And the initial credits appear at the bottom of the screen, so when the ECP appeared they were cut off Embarassed
IS
Inspector Sands
The visual style of the show is pretty much unchanged.

Which is good as it's always been one of the best things about the programme, it's always looked great
IS
Inspector Sands
Here is Extra bit, One has to wonder if this was done to prop up the Online content for BBC3?
http://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/p03w1dcs/top-gear-extra-gear-episode-1

If BBC 3 was still on TV it would be the obvious place to put it. It's the only popular BBC show not to have an 'extra' spin off
VM
VMPhil
I didn't realise Extra Gear was a proper full-length programme of its own. Shame it's hidden away on iPlayer.
DF
DrewF
Overall I think it was still entertaining and it keeps the right balance of cars/fun. Some of it did feel a little forced, but I think it'll settle down into something better. If you've ever seen the first episode of the 2002 reboot you'll be shocked much it changes over the first series, it only really resembles the later series from series 2 (and not just because it has James May in it).
DV
dvboy
I didn't realise Extra Gear was a proper full-length programme of its own. Shame it's hidden away on iPlayer.


It gets a BBC2 airing at 22:00, starting next Sunday, so basically a week after the related show went out.
TV
TVMan
The show needs more audience participation, than we have seen on the first episode. The set doesn't seem to have any other areas for features, so I don't expect much.
DJ
DJGM
OK my verdict after the first show ...

While there's not a huge amount of changes from the Clarkson/Hammond/May format, but presentation wise, I like the new brighter set, but not keen on the TFI style of bringing on the celeb guests. So it's not quite the TFI Top Gear some were fearing it might become, and it still retained certain familiar elements of the Clarkson/Hammond/May era to retain viewers of that era. I think the only people who'll turn off are those that think Chris Evans is a ginger (insert suitably offensive comment here) .

I think the guest seating area they've kept from the C/H/M era could do with being repositioned so the new videowall is centered in a way the flat screen TV was on the old set. Not sure about the raised audience area. Nice touch, but a little too TFI for TG, IMO.

Eitherway, I think this new era of TG has potential, and I'm sure they'll be making a few tweaks to improve the format over time. I hope one of the tweaks they make is adding a third presenter in the studio, in a similar way to how Captain Slow was sometimes presented as the "third wheel" in the relationship ... so to speak.
RD
rdd Founding member
Extra Gear is getting an airing on RTE2, Monday 8:30pm.
BA
bilky asko
The scores on the board with the Vord:



Newer posts