TV Home Forum

Some Mothers Do 'Ave 'Em..in America!

(October 2007)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
CY
cylon6
Fox are going to remake Some Mothers Do 'Ave 'Em for America!

Ooh Betty! Frank remade for US


Stephen Brook
Wednesday October 17, 2007
MediaGuardian.co.uk


Frank Spencer: the hapless hero in the original series of Some Mothers Do 'Av 'Em. Photograph: BBC

Ooh Betty! Have you heard about the most unlikely TV revival of all time - a new American version of the 70s BBC sitcom Some Mothers Do 'Ave 'Em?
The Fox TV network has asked the BBC to make a pilot episode of the comedy, which saw well-meaning disaster zone Frank Spencer try and fail to provide a better life for his long-suffering wife Betty.

Created by Raymond Allen, the original ran for three series from 1973 and propelled Michael Crawford to fame in part because he coupled his effeminate portrayal of the naive Frank with a series of spectacular stunts.

These included a day trip that culminated in Frank hanging from his Morris Minor as it teetered on a cliff edge and a roller-skate ride that saw Spencer crash through doors, shops and even skate under a passing lorry.

"I never would have dreamt 35 years ago when I originally wrote the series that dearly loved but disastrous Frank would be creating havoc on American soil," said Mr Allen. "It's a very exciting time... and a treasured moment of glory for Frank!"

If executives at Rupert Murdoch's Fox network like the slapstick humour, the pilot could spawn an entire series.

Philip Stark, the writer/producer behind That 70s Show and the film Dude Where's My Car, who also worked on South Park, is to adapt, update and executive produce a pilot script for American audiences.

The US remake will be co-produced by Sony Pictures Television and BBC Worldwide, the corporation's commercial arm, which has turned the US version of Strictly Come Dancing, Dancing with the Stars, into a smash hit for ABC. "We have felt for a while now that Some Mothers Do 'Ave 'Em would translate brilliantly across the pond," said Paul Telegdy, executive producer with BBC Worldwide.

"With Philip's exceptional skills on board we're confident we'll produce a winning pilot with the ultimate aim of bringing Ray's fantastic show to millions of US viewers." The BBC has a long history of exporting its comedy across the pond, with the US version of The Office well established on the NBC network.

In the 70s the sitcom Steptoe and Son was turned into Sanford and Son for US audiences.
ST
Stuart
It's too 1970s. Nobody in this country would laugh anymore, although the americans might, as their humour tops out at around age 7.

Why can't people in the industry come up with something new? Have we reached a frontier of humour?

Has it always now got to be a re-write of everything we've already had until we get back as far as the odd witty comment made by the likes of the Venerable Bede in the early 8th Century?
JO
Joe
So is it just me that laughs at them when I see it on TV these days?
CY
cylon6
StuartPlymouth posted:
It's too 1970s. Nobody in this country would laugh anymore, although the americans might, as their humour tops out at around age 7.

Why can't people in the industry come up with something new? Have we reached a frontier of humour?

Has it always now got to be a re-write of everything we've already had until we get back as far as the odd witty comment made by the likes of the Venerable Bede in the early 8th Century?
It's still a laugh out loud funny show after all of these years and Michael Crawford's performance is amazing in terms of timing and stunts. The closest I think America has come to an accident prone person in a sitcom was Tim 'The Tool Man' Taylor in Home Improvement.
JR
jrothwell97
Jugalug posted:
So is it just me that laughs at them when I see it on TV these days?


No.
BR
Brekkie
So do we think it'll be axed after the first episode or the second?
BL
Blob
Some Mothers Do Ave Em is a brilliant programme! Still very funny
CY
cylon6
Blob posted:
Some Mothers Do Ave Em is a brilliant programme! Still very funny
Precisely! I've bought the DVD's and the 1975 Christmas special where he's Learning To Drive is hilarious from start to finish.
ST
Stuart
Blob posted:
Some Mothers Do Ave Em is a brilliant programme! Still very funny

Your humour is clearly stuck in the past.

I don't find SMDAE, The Two Ronnies, Morecambe & Wise, Dick Emery, Tommy Cooper, or Laurel & Hardy in the least bit amusing.

Go and buy the DVDs if you want to watch them. Don't subject the rest of the population to it.
CY
cylon6
StuartPlymouth posted:
Blob posted:
Some Mothers Do Ave Em is a brilliant programme! Still very funny

Your humour is clearly stuck in the past.

I don't find SMDAE, The Two Ronnies, Morecambe & Wise, Dick Emery, Tommy Cooper, or Laurel & Hardy in the least bit amusing.

Go and buy the DVDs if you want to watch them. Don't subject the rest of the population to it.
A lot of these shows still rate rather highly with repeats, but different strokes for different folks I suppose.

I love all of those shows just as much as I love Larry Sanders, Frasier, Seinfeld, Drop The Dead Donkey, One Foot In The Grave, Cheers, The Goodies. The only sitcom that I really cannot stand is Dad's Army. Awful!
PT
Put The Telly On
StuartPlymouth posted:
Blob posted:
Some Mothers Do Ave Em is a brilliant programme! Still very funny

Your humour is clearly stuck in the past.

I don't find SMDAE, The Two Ronnies, Morecambe & Wise, Dick Emery, Tommy Cooper, or Laurel & Hardy in the least bit amusing.

Go and buy the DVDs if you want to watch them. Don't subject the rest of the population to it.


The Two Ronnies? How can you not like The Two Ronnies?

F U E N M? S E F M. Laughing
ST
Stuart
cylon6 posted:
I love Larry Sanders, Frasier, Seinfeld, Drop The Dead Donkey, One Foot In The Grave, Cheers, The Goodies. The only sitcom that I really cannot stand is Dad's Army. Awful!

They are all available on DSat subscription channels. Which I already pay for.

I don't want them manufactured as "new" on BBC One aswell. Is there really no talent to produce new programmes out there?

Newer posts