I've never got all the hate for Scarlet. She's endearing, warm and naturally funny. I don't think she's terrible on anything she done either. People complain about safe pair of hands hosts like Stephen Mulhern but when somebody slightly left of field emerges there are always those who take an irrational disliking to them.
I can't speak for other people who criticise Scarlett Moffatt, but there's no 'hatred' or 'irrational dislike' from me.
My criticisms of her are solely regarding her ability as a TV performer. And, personally, I think she's been very lucky to get the very sudden career that she's had in the last couple of years as I don't think she's got anywhere near enough talent to justify her many appearances on many different TV shows.
Whenever I see her she seems to almost exclusively rely on the 'OMG, I can't believe I'm on here' excited fan role, living out her dreams appearing on shows with people she loves to watch, etc. That might make her likeable and relatable to some, but I prefer to watch stars with genuine talent in their field who clearly possess an ability to a level far higher than members of the public; whereas, to me, Scarlett Moffatt is one of these modern TV personalities who seem to become famous via the likes of reality shows that require no particular talent, and then become established on TV courtesy of regular appearances on the types of shows that don't require them to ever
develop
any particular talent that justifies or explains their fame (i.e. Famous for being famous).
But that's just my view. I totally get it's each to their own and that there'll be plenty who like her. I just, ability-wise, don't rate her.