TV Home Forum

Good Morning Britain

From Television Centre (April 2018)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
NG
noggin Founding member
Scotland did polarised politics long before the rest of the UK had its Brexit debate, and I imagine many people have complained on a constant basis about bias when they've had absolutely no foundation to do so, so you have to ensure you absolutely know what you're talking about before you crash into a Scottish political debate. In this instance, I'm surprised they only got one complaint, because part of that side of the debate is convinced the entire media is out to get them.


That may say something about GMB's current ratings...
WH
Whataday Founding member
Whilst Ben may not be a trained journalist, Kate came up through the TV News ranks. She was a presenter at Meridian, was one of the News 24 launch presenters (Matthew Amroliwala shared a timslot across the week with Kate on News 24 - though they didn't present together) before moving to GMTV.


She very much came through the ranks as a newsreader though rather than a journalist. She was poached by Meridian after the boss saw her presenting a short bulletin on Central, her first TV job where she'd been working barely two years.
SP
Steve in Pudsey

I think the bigger problem with particular incident was probably the summary that was provided to the presenters by the production team. If they had been handed the note and been told "this is a summary of the key points of the report" for example, I would wager that they would just trust that what they had been told by those who produced the notes was correct.


I think a presenter should be entitled to trust the editorial staff on their own show. It sounds like something got misinterpreted and the journalists who prepared the briefing notes were aiming for a question in which Sturgeon would be invited to respond to the claim in the IFS report that Ben was waving around.
AN
Andrew Founding member
Yes in this case it was the briefing notes which were wrong. On a show like GMB, even BBC Breakfast, I doubt the presenter does their own prep on every single story they are covering, there just wouldn’t be enough time, and will rely on briefing notes.
DV
DVB Cornwall
I'd recommend anyone with an interest in the way Ofcom does it's business to read the whole account including the narrative of the discussion in question. Ben Shepard doesn't come out of this at all well, Kate Garraway tries leaping to his defence too at one point.

It's clear that ITV put their hands up on this case and admitted that the complaint was valid. They attempt in their discussion to mitigate the complaint, but then effectively dismiss this mitigation by authorising the broadcast of the heavily delayed apology.

The forensic detail is impressive as it always is in these fortnightly regulatory bulletins.
MA
Markymark
Yes in this case it was the briefing notes which were wrong. On a show like GMB, even BBC Breakfast, I doubt the presenter does their own prep on every single story they are covering, there just wouldn’t be enough time, and will rely on briefing notes.


Indeed. It's a far cry from programmes such as Weekend World, where a large production team would
produce very detailed and accurate notes for Peter Jay/Brian Walden/Matthew Parris to refer to.

Neither breakfast programme has that resource, and as you say, there's multiple stories each morning.
SP
Steve in Pudsey
Nor a whole week to do that kind of prep
SC
scottishtv Founding member
Ofcom posted:
The interview concluded with a lighthearted question about the existence of the Loch Ness Monster.

*cringe*
ET
ethanh05
Ofcom posted:
The interview concluded with a lighthearted question about the existence of the Loch Ness Monster.

*cringe*

As embarrassing as that is, that's one of the most sensible things ever said in an interview on ITV.
MA
Markymark
Nor a whole week to do that kind of prep


Indeed, though I’d expect the modern miracle of t’internet to speed up some of that process (accuracy of on-line sources notwithstanding !)

Perhaps the point is Breakfast telly is not the place for that sort of interview
IS
Inspector Sands
I can't remember who it was but I heard someone say recently that one of the toughest politicians to interview is Sturgeon. She is always very well prepared and really knows her stuff, you don't get much past her.

EDIT: remembered, think it was Cathy Newman of. Channel 4 News
Last edited by Inspector Sands on 23 October 2018 11:17pm
GM
Gary McEwan
I can't remember who it was but I heard someone say recently that one of the toughest politicians to interview is Sturgeon. She is always very well prepared and really knows her stuff, you don't get much past her.


Andrew Neil has got her a cropper on a few occasions and she fell to pieces. Either that or she reverts back to 'Westminster bad, Toaries bad' if she doesn't have an answer.

Newer posts