TV Home Forum

German Big Brother

Taking it too far? (October 2004)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
JO
Joel
From MediaGuardian.co.uk:

http://media.guardian.co.uk/broadcast/story/0,7493,1331795,00.html

MediaGuardian posted:
Big Brother builds 'Truman Show' village

Mike Leidig
Friday October 22, 2004


The Truman Show: German TV plans for an entire community to be scrutinised around the clock

Germany's version of the Big Brother reality TV show will take a giant leap next spring with the opening of a small town mimicking The Truman Show concept.

In the Jim Carrey movie, a man called Truman is unwittingly the subject of a 24-hour TV programme that monitors his every living moment for the gratification of a worldwide audience.

In the city currently being built outside Hamburg the only difference will be that contestants will be willing participants in this next-generation leap into voyeurism.

There will be a forest, a town square complete with shops and a church tower, schools and businesses. Contestants will, it is hoped, live there for years; falling in love, going to school, even getting married. The producers hope to lure in businesses to employ them, teachers to teach them and doctors to care for the sick.

Producer Rainert Laux said: "We hope couples will get pregnant and family groups will interact with all the usual family frictions."

He said they would handpick the "very best group, all unemployed" to live in what will be a cross between the Truman Show and Disneyworld.

"They can do exams there if they want to go to school, learn languages or any other type of professional examination for a career and eventual employment."

Contestants will live in the city for years and it will be as realistic as possible so they have no problems reintegrating into society. But the company was unable to provide details on financing for such an ambitious scheme.

Producers of the new show say the present format has had its day. The plan now is for an entire community to be scrutinised around the clock. As long as such a show draws viewers it will remain on air.

The Carrey film was a dark fantasy whereby unassuming salesman Truman Burbank grows up in a city that is actually a vast studio without knowing that his every action is broadcast to the outside world in a soap opera without limits.

Broadcaster RTL2's idea is not quite so ambitious - but nearly. Its Big Brother city, built from scratch along the lines of a theme park, will afford fans of the show visits to the community to see the residents just as if they were visiting a zoo.

The show is planned to start screening in March next year on a 17,000sq ft piece of land.

Insiders say the show will initially be broadcast 24 hours a day on the internet, with highlights screened in an evening show seven days a week. If viewer interest is strong, the broadcasts will go live around the clock.

The ambitious project will seek dozens if not hundreds of contestants but will follow the central tenet of the existing Big Brother: sex, difficult situations and the eternal fascination of human nature.

Media psychologist Jo Graibel voiced concerns that people who stayed in the fake community for any length of time would find it hard to adjust to the "real world" beyond.


Is this taking reality tv too far?
BR
Brekkie
Considering the current year-long version of Big Brother in Germany is considered a flop, I'm surprised at this.

The strength of Big Brother is it has a definitive beginning (the launch, getting to know housemates), middle (the evictions and tasks etc) and end (the grand final). This has already been lost with the year-long version - after a couple of months you just want a winner!

This new plan doesn't sound good - and spread far to thinly with nightly shows. I think it could work if a new community was set up and filmed, with regular series updating events - but contestants able to leave the community as regularly as you would leave your own community.

However, remember Forever Eden - the US reality show that had no planned ending. It lasted six weeks!
:-(
A former member
Hi Folks

Totally boggling that something on this scale, purporting to ring at all true with humankind, can possibly be afforded - but, who knows?

So, hands up who is wondering whether our existence on Planet Earth is some(cosmic)body's terrarium or theme park?

Cool
MD
Mr D'Arcy
I think it's a great idea, we could build one here, put every idiot that has produced or appeared on a stupid Reality TV over the last couple of years and throw away the key. They could even be a I used to be a Celeb version too.

That'll clear the schedules of this mindless drivel.
LU
luke-h
Not fully, for on E4 they'll be "Thrown Away The Key - LIVE!", with a 24 hour live feed of reality TV stars commiting suicide and eating each other.
JA
jay Founding member
As long as 'Big Brother' dosn't tell them how to live their lives, I see no harm! It's just like living on your street at the minute, only you'd be watched 24/7 for the rest of your life! Think it's a pretty cool idea, reminds me of The Sims!

13 days later

:-(
A former member
Roxof posted:
Hi Folks

Totally boggling that something on this scale, purporting to ring at all true with humankind, can possibly be afforded - but, who knows?

So, hands up who is wondering whether our existence on Planet Earth is some(cosmic)body's terrarium or theme park?

Cool


A South Park episode recently portrayed the entire planet earth as one huge reality TV show for the rest of the universe to laugh at. It gets more and more difficult to watch that episode without thinking how close we are pushing ourselves to creating that for ourselves, never mind someone else doing it for us.
Having said that, I find myself very intrigued by this new idea. Perhaps it will highlight flaws in the way people are brought up, flaws in society, and help us to rectify things about our own civilisation. It could provide a very good experimental insight into our own human nature. I'm pretty sure, however, that this won't happen. It'll be another reality TV show where the contestants never live a true moment or say a true word in their entire time on the program. The only way reality TV can every be truly created is if the participants don't know about it. This is still an interesting idea, nonetheless.

Newer posts