TV Home Forum

Electric Proms

Scheduling cowardice (October 2009)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
MO
Moz
Back in the day, top stars giving their all for the BBC would have been given prime time slots.

Tonight, Robbie Williams's come back is on BBC Two at 11.20.

Shouldn't this sort of thing - and I include all of the Electric Proms - be on BBC One prime time Saturday, either after Strictly and/or against X-Factor.
CH
Chie
Moz posted:
top stars giving their all for the BBC


I think they're "giving their all" for their own careers, Moz, I doubt they give a stuff about the BBC.

Moz posted:
Shouldn't this sort of thing - and I include all of the Electric Proms - be on BBC One prime time Saturday, either after Strictly and/or against X-Factor.


Why against X Factor specifically?
MO
Moz
Chie posted:
Moz posted:
top stars giving their all for the BBC


I think they're "giving their all" for their own careers, Moz, I doubt they give a stuff about the BBC.

Moz posted:
Shouldn't this sort of thing - and I include all of the Electric Proms - be on BBC One prime time Saturday, either after Strictly and/or against X-Factor.


Why against X Factor specifically?


Yes, of course for their own careers - was always thus - but what I meant was it's BBC exclusive and they shove it late night BBC Two.

Why X Factor? Coz that's ITV's big family entertainment show. BBC should be putting proper talent up against it rather than scheduling it late at night on the second channel.
CH
Chie
Moz posted:
Yes, of course for their own careers - was always thus - but what I meant was it's BBC exclusive and they shove it late night BBC Two.

I don't know if you're aware, but Robbie actually launched his come back on The X Factor on ITV more than a week ago.

Moz posted:
Why X Factor? Coz that's ITV's big family entertainment show. BBC should be putting proper talent up against it rather than scheduling it late at night on the second channel.

Well the two programmes are very different.

There's not really much to be gained from watching Robbie Williams perform live. I had Electric Proms on in the background here and the songs sounded exactly the same as the album versions, which you can simply download any time or hear on the radio x number of times a week. So on that basis, I don't think the show warrants prime time status. It just wasn't special enough.

Having said that, I always thought the BBC One Sessions were on too late, but the difference there is that the performances usually varied quite a bit from the commercial recordings.

The other point is that Electric Proms isn't really a family entertainment show anyway. It would be more or less like having Later With Jools Holland on at 8pm on a Saturday evening. Wouldn't get many viewers, and the BBC would probably feel the need to dumb the presentation down considerably as well.
BE
besty
Plus the BBC would likely get accused of the show being basically an extended advert for his new album in prime time, something they are probably keen to avoid after the criticism of the blanket U2 at the BBC day earlier this year
SW
Steve Williams
Chie posted:
The other point is that Electric Proms isn't really a family entertainment show anyway. It would be more or less like having Later With Jools Holland on at 8pm on a Saturday evening. Wouldn't get many viewers, and the BBC would probably feel the need to dumb the presentation down considerably as well.


Later with Jools Holland was on at 8pm on a Saturday evening for a while, they moved it there in 1994 for a series but, natch, it didn't rate very well and was back at eleven o'clock the next year.
RR
RR
Chie posted:
There's not really much to be gained from watching Robbie Williams perform live. I had Electric Proms on in the background here and the songs sounded exactly the same as the album versions, which you can simply download any time or hear on the radio x number of times a week. So on that basis, I don't think the show warrants prime time status. It just wasn't special enough.
I didn't think the album was out until the middle of next month?

Newer posts