TV Home Forum

Doctor Who: The New Series

(February 2005)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
DA
David_02
This episode was definitely one of the best of the series so far. Billie Piper is just getting better and better IMO.
MD
Mr D'Arcy
Well I have never cried watching Doctor Who before, each and every episode has been totally different to the other!

I must go now I need to fix my make-up, sniffle! Smile
IS
Isonstine Founding member
Well what a fantastic episode.

It was truly sensational and possibly one of the best yet - next to the Dalek episode of course.

Well done to all involved - I don't think ITV could put anything up against it and win...great writing, great acting, great programme. Great stuff!
GR
Greg
That was a wonderful episode, The car going round and round and round. LOL Laughing
CY
cylon6
Could anyone believe it when The Doctor was devoured!?! Shocked
TV
TVDragon
Aww I really did enjoy that too -- slightly frightening at one point and of course terribly moving at the end.

The changing history thingyo needed to be addressed in its own episode [at least] -- it's the first thing newer viewers would think of with a concept like this surely.
NI
nidave
For it to be a true paradox Rose should have been driving the car that killed her father.
She would also have had to go back to the time when she saved her dad.

It would have made a much better and emotional episode.
SM
smtver
the best of the box posted:
That was a wonderful episode, The car going round and round and round. LOL Laughing

I think everyone was laughing at that!
CY
cylon6
Why wasn't there an explosion when the two Roses touched each other? We've always been told how there'll be an explosion if the same person from different times touch each other. Confused
LE
Lee
nidave posted:
For it to be a true paradox Rose should have been driving the car that killed her father.
She would also have had to go back to the time when she saved her dad.

It would have made a much better and emotional episode.


But Rose would've been a baby at the time her father was originally killed. I'd have to disagree that it would've been better like that anyway, I think what added to the emotion in this episode was the fact that Rose never knew her father.

I keep finding myself wondering each week if it's worth watching the next episode, I keep expecting it to die down and get a little boring, but it's not!
SP
Sput
cylon6 posted:
Why wasn't there an explosion when the two Roses touched each other? We've always been told how there'll be an explosion if the same person from different times touch each other. Confused


By whom? It's clear from Back to the Future that people just faint.
SP
Sput
Lee S posted:
But Rose would've been a baby at the time her father was originally killed. I'd have to disagree that it would've been better like that anyway, I think what added to the emotion in this episode was the fact that Rose never knew her father.

I keep finding myself wondering each week if it's worth watching the next episode, I keep expecting it to die down and get a little boring, but it's not!


Nononono, he means the Rose from the future. Now THAT is some causality fun!

Newer posts