TV Home Forum

Doctor Who - Discussions on Season 5 onwards

Spoiler Free Please (March 2007)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
AM
amosc100
Ronnie Rowlands posted:
He, strictly speaking, was not a companion, he worked for UNIT. It was important to have them around for the earth bound stories.


That's why it was put in speech parenthesis - although even after he left UNIT he still helped the Doctor (Turlough's introductory story - part of the Black Guardian Trilogy - and Battlefield being 2 of the more famous ex-UNIT stories) and he has travelled in the Tardis numerous times - like Mickey Smith - another "assistant"

For me, bringing back the characters every now and again shows that there is continuity within the show and that past assistants are never forgotten about.
SA
saturdaymorning
Yeah.And lets run through the new series ones.

Adam-Probably in a mental asylum now.I don't like how the Doctor dealt with him.I doubt he'll be in the finale even if they all do come back.

Capt Jack-Probably back in Torchwood.

Rose-Stuck in a parallel universe.Isn't there another parallel universe he could get her from?

Donna-She's coming back so she's OK.

Martha-Same as Donna.
AM
amosc100
saturdaymorning posted:
Yeah.And lets run through the new series ones.

Adam-Probably in a mental asylum now.I don't like how the Doctor dealt with him.I doubt he'll be in the finale even if they all do come back.

Capt Jack-Probably back in Torchwood.

Rose-Stuck in a parallel universe.Isn't there another parallel universe he could get her from?

Donna-She's coming back so she's OK.

Martha-Same as Donna.


TBH I do not think that Adam was the Doctors assistant/companion as he only got on board the TARDIS due to Rose! The Doctor never liked him anyway!!!!!!

Rose is back for the final 3 episodes of the new season,

Jack is definitely coming back towards the end of the season - presumably around the same time as Martha - Torchwood connection!!!!!

Astrid - only if its true that she was the manifestation of the TARDIS, as some papers say!!!!!!
SA
saturdaymorning
amosc100 posted:
TBH I do not think that Adam was the Doctors assistant/companion as he only got on board the TARDIS due to Rose! The Doctor never liked him anyway!!!!!!


He does count.
AM
amosc100
saturdaymorning posted:
amosc100 posted:
TBH I do not think that Adam was the Doctors assistant/companion as he only got on board the TARDIS due to Rose! The Doctor never liked him anyway!!!!!!


He does count.


Why does he count? - if its becuase he has travelled in the TARDIS then so has Jackie, Rose's Dad, K9 (MKiv) and many other sub-characters including the mother Slitheen but they were not assistants. Adam never actually helped the Doctor in anyway - he was more of a hinderance rather than a help - he was out for himself which yje Doctor did not like and was only in 2 epiosdes btw!!!!!

Even a Dalek has been on baord the TARDIS in New Doctor Who (Parting of the ways) and don't forget that the console was once shot by a Cyberman in the TARDIS (Earthshock) but they have never been assistants!!!

Anyone remember Chemeleon - now that was meant to be an assistant for the doctor but never worked - could it work in today's world of Who?
SA
saturdaymorning
Yeah,well the doctor was being a private part.
:-(
A former member
saturdaymorning posted:
Yeah,well the doctor was being a private part.


what this all about?
JO
Johnny83
Thought people would like to see this nice tribute to one of the greatest Doctors in the shows history, Patrick Troughton:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1Xm26StUZVY&feature=related

I Don't think I have posted this before, apologies if I have
CY
cylon6
Ladies and gentlemen the Christmas edition of Doctor Who was the second most watched show of 2007 with 13.31 million!!! Shocked
:-(
A former member
and yet many people did not like it, has the doctor gone main-stream
JO
Johnny83
The core fans won't be too pleased Wink Laughing
UB
Ubernerd
Core fan here!

Not too impressed with Voyage personally, but as a long term fan I am so pleased of the sucess Doctor Who is having!

The ammount of bullying and mockery for being a Who fan as a kid... then in my first year in college, I was suddenly popular! (That was in 2005)

Newer posts