TV Home Forum

Did 'Who Wants to be a Millionaire' kill the gameshow?

(February 2007)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
JO
Johnny83
Jez posted:
Johnny83 posted:
i would say that The Weakest Link is more responsible than WWTBAM mainly as they have had far more "special editions" than WWTBAM



What about all the celeb versions of WWTBAM?


But there have been less specials of WWTBAM than TWL hasn't there? (Seems like they have had many more versions)
PT
Put The Telly On
bee bee see posted:
Ant posted:
Yeah I agree about Millionaire and the Weakest Link. Both shows are well past their sell-by dates. I loved watching both when they started but I gave up on them pretty much about 5 years ago. I can see Deal or No Deal's figures going down at some point in the near future.

PokerFace is quite good. Nice having a fresh idea for a change.


Technically it has, because the £250,000 has now been won, so the big draw has now gone. Not much else to watch for, unless the Banker appears, which seems quite doubtful.


Well they could up the amount to £500.000 more often - which is probably what they'll end up doing.
JE
Jez Founding member
Johnny83 posted:
Jez posted:
Johnny83 posted:
i would say that The Weakest Link is more responsible than WWTBAM mainly as they have had far more "special editions" than WWTBAM



What about all the celeb versions of WWTBAM?


But there have been less specials of WWTBAM than TWL hasn't there? (Seems like they have had many more versions)


Has there? I notice half the time when WWTBAM is on the air it seems to be a celeb version - especially over Christmas.
JO
Johnny83
Jez posted:
Johnny83 posted:
Jez posted:
Johnny83 posted:
i would say that The Weakest Link is more responsible than WWTBAM mainly as they have had far more "special editions" than WWTBAM



What about all the celeb versions of WWTBAM?


But there have been less specials of WWTBAM than TWL hasn't there? (Seems like they have had many more versions)


Has there? I notice half the time when WWTBAM is on the air it seems to be a celeb version - especially over Christmas.


Probably, I'll be honest I don't watch either anymore as they have been done to death
JE
Jez Founding member
Johnny83 posted:
Jez posted:
Johnny83 posted:
Jez posted:
Johnny83 posted:
i would say that The Weakest Link is more responsible than WWTBAM mainly as they have had far more "special editions" than WWTBAM



What about all the celeb versions of WWTBAM?


But there have been less specials of WWTBAM than TWL hasn't there? (Seems like they have had many more versions)


Has there? I notice half the time when WWTBAM is on the air it seems to be a celeb version - especially over Christmas.


Probably, I'll be honest I don't watch either anymore as they have been done to death


Me neither.

Its an example of why they shouldnt show something so often just because it is a ratings sucess.
AN
Andrew Founding member
Jez posted:
Johnny83 posted:
Jez posted:
Johnny83 posted:
i would say that The Weakest Link is more responsible than WWTBAM mainly as they have had far more "special editions" than WWTBAM



What about all the celeb versions of WWTBAM?


But there have been less specials of WWTBAM than TWL hasn't there? (Seems like they have had many more versions)


Has there? I notice half the time when WWTBAM is on the air it seems to be a celeb version - especially over Christmas.

Well for a start every prime time edition of Weakest Link is a celeb special

Also with WWTBAM it's 2 celebs an episode, obviously TWL needs many more per episode so they have done every possible combination of Z list celebs
JE
Jez Founding member
Andrew posted:
Jez posted:
Johnny83 posted:
Jez posted:
Johnny83 posted:
i would say that The Weakest Link is more responsible than WWTBAM mainly as they have had far more "special editions" than WWTBAM



What about all the celeb versions of WWTBAM?


But there have been less specials of WWTBAM than TWL hasn't there? (Seems like they have had many more versions)


Has there? I notice half the time when WWTBAM is on the air it seems to be a celeb version - especially over Christmas.

Well for a start every prime time edition of Weakest Link is a celeb special

Also with WWTBAM it's 2 celebs an episode, obviously TWL needs many more per episode so they have done every possible combination of Z list celebs


I find the pace of TWL better than WWTBAM though - celebs or no celebs its just boring now.
MU
mulder
Pootle5 posted:
Yes I think it has killed the gameshow.

Everything seems to want to imitate it; the music, lights, set...

But worse of all is the grinding slowness of it all! It's so boring! So many shows have the "is it this, is it that" element with one question taking about 5 minutes to answer.

The "quick fire" quizzes and game shows of the past were so much better, Bob's Full House for example, (ok a bit cheesy) allowed Bob to really build up to the end with questions coming thick and fast - none of this dilly-dallying and pondering and fake tension building with music and lights on sometimes depressingly easy questions.


I'm not even going to read the rest of the thread, that was just spot on Pootle! I hate this kind of game show, always have.
BS
brotherton sands
I vaguely remember a gameshow in the early 1990s (I think) with Chris Tarrant called " Lose A Million ". I think it only ever had one series.

My memories are sketchy, but here's what I think I remember...

The title sequence was preceeded by what sounded like Honor Blackman's voiceover, introducing the three contestants (e.g. "John Smith, a civil servant from Bristol" etc), which would always end with: "Tonight, these three people are here to... Lose A Million!"

Title sequence was (computer(?))-animated, and featured a luxury cruise ferry. The studio set was also like a cruise-liner, I think. Contestants started off with an imaginary £1million, which they had to lose during the course of the the game. This being pre-WWTBAM era, the most a contestant could actually leave with was several thousand £s, nowhere near £1million. I don't recall whether there were also non-cash prizes.

I seem to remember that one round within the show was like the Two Ronnies' "Mastermind" sketch (i.e. answering the previous question, to comic effect).

Although I don't remember it very clearly, I remember liking it - manily because of the "previous question"-style game! Any format that I really like only ever seems to have about one series.

I'd love to see that back!

Does anyone else remember it? Or did I imagine the whole thing?
JO
Jonny
Work of Artifice posted:
I vaguely remember a gameshow in the early 1990s (I think) with Chris Tarrant called " Lose A Million ". I think it only ever had one series.

My memories are sketchy, but here's what I think I remember...

The title sequence was preceeded by what sounded like Honor Blackman's voiceover, introducing the three contestants (e.g. "John Smith, a civil servant from Bristol" etc), which would always end with: "Tonight, these three people are here to... Lose A Million!"

Title sequence was (computer(?))-animated, and featured a luxury cruise ferry. The studio set was also like a cruise-liner, I think. Contestants started off with an imaginary £1million, which they had to lose during the course of the the game. This being pre-WWTBAM era, the most a contestant could actually leave with was several thousand £s, nowhere near £1million. I don't recall whether there were also non-cash prizes.

I seem to remember that one round within the show was like the Two Ronnies' "Mastermind" sketch (i.e. answering the previous question, to comic effect).

Although I don't remember it very clearly, I remember liking it - manily because of the "previous question"-style game! Any format that I really like only ever seems to have about one series.

I'd love to see that back!

Does anyone else remember it? Or did I imagine the whole thing?

Here's a nice page devoted to it: Click
http://www.ukgameshows.com/atoz/programmes/l/lose_a_million/lose%20a%20million%202.jpg
BS
brotherton sands
plucky duck92 posted:


Cheers for that. I also was rather fond of Channel 5's " Whittle ", which itself was almost exactly the same as ITV's " Everybody's Equal " (another Chris Tarrant one! Laughing Rolling Eyes ), some years earlier...
RO
rob Founding member
Channel 5's One To Win was a direct rip off of Going For Gold...

Newer posts