TV Home Forum

Dancing on Ice 2019

(December 2018)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
TV
TVEngineer
Apart from the rebuilding the entire studio (studio, not set) and including a bigger ice rink and bigger audience as part of that. Visually though I don't think it'll look much different.


Same location, and still a giant marquee?

*watches weather forecast with morbid curiosity* Laughing
BR
Brekkie
I don't think there is actualy a risk of any one getting killed in DOI I think you may be getting it confused with The Jump where that was a distinct possibilty

There was last year with their makeshift studio during the storm.
SE
Square Eyes Founding member
The weather is probably not the main concern given that the studio is right next door to a prison.
GB
Gary Baldy
I’ve watched DOI since its inception, but it feels like a completely different show now. I think the producers noticed that Strictly was much better, so they just made everything that was unique about DOI to the Strictly way of doing things, e.g- Scores out of 10 instead of 6, having the head judge(s) be the most respected/famous names in their particular fields ( Torvill and Dean are known worldwide, as are Len Goodman and Shirley Ballas to ballroom and latin dancers), the scoring graphics are very Strictly, and even the ‘mean’ judge sits in the same seat on both shows now (left hand side of the screen).
For years, I’ve thought of Jason Gardiner as a poor man’s Craig Revel Horwood, and with all these changes to DOI, it makes it increasingly obvious.
Also Torvill and Dean don’t suit the judging role, as they seem like lovely people, who would be difficult to picture being harsh.
BR
Brekkie
I would say kost of them are coincidences rather than deliberate but must add the new raised position for the rival stars felt very Clauditorium too.
TT
ThatTVNerd
After watching the first episode of the new series on catch-up the other day, DOI just doesn't have that spark as it once had. What gets me is that the celebrities are supposedly in training for three months prior to their first live performances, but it doesn't come across that way with a lot of them.

I agree with you Gary about Torvill and Dean, they are too nice to be judges. They are much suited as
being coaches/choreographers in my opinion. I also used to the like the old title sequences too, I'm not so keen on the current logo.
PF
PFML84
Like Big Brother, it might provide rare moments of brilliance, but it should have been left alone when it was axed the first time. After all, it was axed for a reason.
CA
cal0906
I agree that it’s lost it’s spark. Dancing On Ice used to provide hugely spoken about moments of TV- who can forget Todd Carty skating off the ice, Hayley’s Jai Ho, Jason VS Karen, Suzanne’s flying etc

It just feels like a parody now
SW
Steve Williams
Scores out of 10 instead of 6, having the head judge(s) be the most respected/famous names in their particular fields ( Torvill and Dean are known worldwide, as are Len Goodman and Shirley Ballas to ballroom and latin dancers), the scoring graphics are very Strictly, and even the ‘mean’ judge sits in the same seat on both shows now (left hand side of the screen).
For years, I’ve thought of Jason Gardiner as a poor man’s Craig Revel Horwood, and with all these changes to DOI, it makes it increasingly obvious.


The producers of Strictly explained why Craig sits on the left - on the first show, he sat on the right but, because his marks were lower than everyone else's, whenever they were doing the scores they would always finish on a bit of an anti-climax. So on show two he swapped with Bruno, which means you now generally get the scores increasing as you go along and that makes it all seem that bit nicer and you end on a high note.

Craig works on Strictly because he's always the first to send himself up, in a way Jason Gardiner doesn't so he just seems pointlessly nasty.
cal0906 and Jamesypoo gave kudos
:-(
A former member
Like Big Brother, it might provide rare moments of brilliance, but it should have been left alone when it was axed the first time. After all, it was axed for a reason.


But was it axed? Wans't the contract just not renewed?
JA
Jamesypoo
Craig works on Strictly because he's always the first to send himself up, in a way Jason Gardiner doesn't so he just seems pointlessly nasty.

This. Craig is a pantomime character and plays on it very well. Just look at how he behaves/acts during the main bulk of the show compared to the judges chat in the Clauditorium on the Sunday show where he's nice as pie and laughing and joking with the rest. You just *know* that Jason wouldn't be like that - he's just purely charmlessly nasty.
BR
Brekkie
I think that's a bit harsh and just excusing one person's behaviour as he is a bit more successful. I don't see Jason as any harsher at all - just lacks the wit of Craig.

Newer posts