TV Home Forum

Comic Relief

Lacking the atmosphere of the past? (March 2011)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
WH
Whataday Founding member
I would say the negative comments on here are an indication that you are, dare I say, I little past it Wink

The concept of dipping in and out of television is even more relevant than ever before, with most young viewers keeping one eye on the TV, one eye on Twitter.

This was a perfect way of remodelling Red Nose Day for a new generation, with the presentation consisting of bitesize chunks of micro events to discuss on the likes of twitter etc, and to download on itunes. The old style telethon is better suited to CiN.

People are raving about Adele's performance, and the Smithy sketch, the Inbetweeners etc. It has still made an impact, but maybe not with the people that used to long for Dawn French to snog Hugh Grant or to see Chris Evans drop a cow pat on Patsy Palmer's head.

However, I would say that the order was a bit out. Alan Carr shouldve been on a lot earlier, with perhaps Jonathan Ross taking the last slot. The totaliser had no sense of importance (although perhaps this was deliberate and they didnt want to place such an emphasis on figures in these hard times).

Oh, and the Downtown Abbey thing just wasn't funny and past it. And that's coming from a French & Saunders/Victoria Wood fan.

Personally, I would have loved to have seen Dawn and Lenny hosting together, to give it a bit of a shock 'must watch' factor. But apart from that it was a good fundraiser overall (including the lead up events) and definitely talked about. Not least, a highly SUCCESSFUL fundraiser.
BR
Brekkie
JCB posted:
Quote:
Yes the Ricky Gervais sketches were very odd, and unfunny


Karl made himself look like a bit of a **** tbh.

Presentation wise; the set reflects the direction the show has gone down these past few years - slick but dull . To be fair they still raised over 70 million so it seems unfair to tell them what they're doing "wrong" but it is a shame Comic Relief has lost it's quirkiness and energy.

That just about sums it up - and just makes it safe. Even simple things like the outrageous suits Lenny would wear in the past seem to have gone - everyone was styled and very coordinated last night.

The second half was definately an improvement on the first, but the entire show had nothing of note happen live - and that's what they really need to change for next time around. I don't buy into the argument that other methods are now more effective than a telethon - I'd guess more than half the money from last night came directly by donations, and £74m cannot be dismissed. I think though the show just needs a bit of a kick up the backside - as indeed does Red Nose Day itself - they seem to have been using this "Do Something Funny for Money" slogan a few years now.

One thing I did like though last night was Lenny Henry having a presence throughout, but it just needs to find it's edge once again.
NG
noggin Founding member
Surprised no-one has commented on the rather poorly adapted ident - Dog Display Team with an added red nose : http://tiggo.at/?M8KG2


What was bad, was the phone number DOG throughout the show. Certainly wasn't generated in the HD domain, seemed sub SD, and with artefacts ?


Almost certainly an upconverted SD graphics box... There are still a lot of Astons in TVC galleries - even the HD ones...
DB
dbl
Is there a reason why Comic Relief went out in SD this year? Isn't TC1 HD equipped?
VM
VMPhil
dbl posted:
Is there a reason why Comic Relief went out in SD this year? Isn't TC1 HD equipped?


...it didn't?

The on-screen caption was SD, but everything else was HD.
DB
dbl
It was?! Didn't look/feel 'HD' to me, high quality upscale at best. I was trying to figure it out, because as mentioned in previous posts the graphics looked alised and not 'sharp'.
IS
Inspector Sands
I meant as in advertising, I didn't see much advertising of the event itself, as in previous years.

I was an avid watcher of the Chris Moyles event!


That's a point, there weren't any/many? Red nose advert or co-operations with big supermarkets etc.

Chris Moyles' long show did seem to be sidelined a bit by Comic Relief and the rest of the BBC, I hope it got a big mention on the night?
JA
james
dbl posted:
Is there a reason why Comic Relief went out in SD this year? Isn't TC1 HD equipped?


...it didn't?

The on-screen caption was SD, but everything else was HD.


Even if it was in HD and not upscaled I was surprised when BBC One switched to BBC Two, the BBC Two part of Comic Relief wasn't shown on BBC HD for the people who wanted to watch the whole coverage of the event in HD.
VM
VMPhil
james posted:
dbl posted:
Is there a reason why Comic Relief went out in SD this year? Isn't TC1 HD equipped?


...it didn't?

The on-screen caption was SD, but everything else was HD.


Even if it was in HD and not upscaled I was surprised when BBC One switched to BBC Two, the BBC Two part of Comic Relief wasn't shown on BBC HD for the people who wanted to watch the whole coverage of the event in HD.


Hold on, it was! I watched it on BBC HD!
JA
james
Was it? I know BBC One HD were broadcasting RND 11. At 10 I switched over to BBC HD when the news was on air and saw something that wasn't Comic Relief.
VM
VMPhil
Did you switch to it between 10-10.30? As the schedules were changed at the last minute to move the news back to ten o'clock, but the EPG still said news at 10.30 and Comic Relief up until then.
DO
dosxuk
http://www.bbc.co.uk/bbchd/programmes/schedules/2011/03/18

Newer posts