TV Home Forum

Comic Relief 2013 - Mildly Amusing at Times for Money

Tumble Tower's Verdict: Dross (March 2013)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
WH
Whataday Founding member
They also never reveal how much is donated as a direct result of the TV telethon. The vast majority probably comes in from schools and workplaces, so saying the show is good because it raised 75m isn't entirely correct.


Anyway, I like the way they used Lenny Henry last night, being a 3rd presenter poping up occasionally so he is still associated with the show. This could be the way Terry Wogan is used on CiN when he decides to step aside.

I also found it a bit odd that they featured a sketch using the word "shag" at 7:30pm. It's almost like they were deliberately asking for trouble for the sake of it. No reason why the sketch couldn't have aired later.


I seem to remember a figure somewhere that just 8% of viewers donate, but that might be outdated. In 2011 they raised £15million by SMS donations.
DA
davidhorman
Last night I watched Comic Relief [...] Very few songs

*facepalm*

Quote:
Remember my criticism about RND 2009? [...] you must know / remember what I mean.

Dear lord, why? Why would you think anyone would remember? I wouldn't remember what Christopher Biggins himself thought about it after four years if he'd come round to tell me on the night.
DA
David
Quote:
Remember my criticism about RND 2009? [...] you must know / remember what I mean.

Dear lord, why? Why would you think anyone would remember? I wouldn't remember what Christopher Biggins himself thought about it after four years if he'd come round to tell me on the night.


You might have a problem with your memory. I think most of us remember. Does "Tommy Rot" ring any bells?
BR
Brekkie
Simply refocus and revitalise the product, and to some extent zone it, it's tired now.

£75m suggests otherwise, and that's the figure that matters.


It's perhaps worth pointing out that correcting for inflation, that's quite a substantial drop on the 2011 figure. Also, this year's £75m includes £16m from Government via DfID, compared with £10m included in the 2011 figure, so the amount donated by the public even without correcting for inflation has decreased by several million pounds.

Given the economic climate, the amount raised clearly represents a massive achievement; yet there's certainly an argument for reviewing their approach.

It was never quite made clear whether the £16m from the Government or the £5m from Bill Gates was added to the total - I'm guessing the way the total jumped in the 9pm hour the former at least must have been. On the night though all the corporate donations combined (and remember the bulk of them is through the general public either buying products or sponsoring staff) can't have topped much more than £25m, so that is still £50m or so donated on the night. It's an assumption I know but I'd assume the bulk of money raised through fundraising finds it's way to Comic Relief after the telethon, so is part of the total that'll top £100m when it's eventually announced.
TT
Tumble Tower
DJGM posted:
Seriously WTF?!? If any of that dross featured on Comic Relief (or CiN) everyone would turn over to something else!

Well I think the Friday evening entertainment the Roller Coaster Club of Great Britain (RCCGB) has enjoyed the Friday evening of the Blackpool Bash each year 2008 to 2012 has been better than the dull and boring dross that was on Comic Relief: Funny For Money Friday 15 March 2013.

2008: John Garland (puppeteer), Phoenix International (illusionist), Jimmy Cricket (comedian)
2009: Carl Schofield (comedian), Brian Sefton (magician), Craig Harper (comedian)
2010: Rob Gaffney (magician), Bob Wooding (balloon modelling), Bobby Knutt (comedian)
2011: Mike McGuire, Lee De Johns (cabaret style act)
2012: Sean Macrae, Tony Jo

All top class acts in my opinion. What a pity there was nothing like that to entertain the public for Comic Relief 2013.
JO
Jon
All top class acts in my opinion. What a pity there was nothing like that to entertain the public for Comic Relief 2013.

The thing you don't realise is, you're in no way representative of the British public as whole.

It's quite clear from previous posts, you don't understand most comedy. You fail to even understand whether something is designed to be comedic a lot of the time. So it's understandable, you wouldn't like Comic Relief, if you don't get most of it.
DJ
DJGM

Well I think the Friday evening entertainment the Roller Coaster Club of Great Britain (RCCGB) has enjoyed
the Friday evening of the Blackpool Bash each year 2008 to 2012 has been better than the dull and boring
dross that was on Comic Relief: Funny For Money Friday 15 March 2013.

2008: John Garland (puppeteer), Phoenix International (illusionist), Jimmy Cricket (comedian)
2009: Carl Schofield (comedian), Brian Sefton (magician), Craig Harper (comedian)
2010: Rob Gaffney (magician), Bob Wooding (balloon modelling), Bobby Knutt (comedian)
2011: Mike McGuire, Lee De Johns (cabaret style act)
2012: Sean Macrae, Tony Jo

All top class acts in my opinion. What a pity there was nothing like that to entertain the public for Comic Relief 2013.


None of those acts would ever appear on Comic Relief, Children In Need or any other big TV charity telethon event.
Well, except maybe the only name that I recognise from that lot, Jimmy Cricket ... although it isn't 1983 anymore!

The nearest any of the others might get to appearing on TV would probably be the auditions for BGT!
TT
Tumble Tower
DJGM posted:
None of those acts would ever appear on Comic Relief, Children In Need or any other big TV charity telethon event.
Well, except maybe the only name that I recognise from that lot, Jimmy Cricket ... although it isn't 1983 anymore!

The nearest any of the others might get to appearing on TV would probably be the auditions for BGT!

Why do you associate Jimmy Cricket with 1983? Is that when he last appeared on TV?
BA
bilky asko
DJGM posted:
Seriously WTF?!? If any of that dross featured on Comic Relief (or CiN) everyone would turn over to something else!

Well I think the Friday evening entertainment the Roller Coaster Club of Great Britain (RCCGB) has enjoyed the Friday evening of the Blackpool Bash each year 2008 to 2012 has been better than the dull and boring dross that was on Comic Relief: Funny For Money Friday 15 March 2013.

2008: John Garland (puppeteer), Phoenix International (illusionist), Jimmy Cricket (comedian)
2009: Carl Schofield (comedian), Brian Sefton (magician), Craig Harper (comedian)
2010: Rob Gaffney (magician), Bob Wooding (balloon modelling), Bobby Knutt (comedian)
2011: Mike McGuire, Lee De Johns (cabaret style act)
2012: Sean Macrae, Tony Jo

All top class acts in my opinion. What a pity there was nothing like that to entertain the public for Comic Relief 2013.

Those people are no Jimmy Frinton, Ian Crawford, or Andy Hodgson - the acts on Comic Relief 2013 were much closer to that calibre.

I have to agree with others in saying that you clearly don't understand the concept of Comic Relief, and perhaps don't understand the humour presented in the telethon.
BR
Brekkie
DJGM posted:

Well I think the Friday evening entertainment the Roller Coaster Club of Great Britain (RCCGB) has enjoyed
the Friday evening of the Blackpool Bash each year 2008 to 2012 has been better than the dull and boring
dross that was on Comic Relief: Funny For Money Friday 15 March 2013.

2008: John Garland (puppeteer), Phoenix International (illusionist), Jimmy Cricket (comedian)
2009: Carl Schofield (comedian), Brian Sefton (magician), Craig Harper (comedian)
2010: Rob Gaffney (magician), Bob Wooding (balloon modelling), Bobby Knutt (comedian)
2011: Mike McGuire, Lee De Johns (cabaret style act)
2012: Sean Macrae, Tony Jo

All top class acts in my opinion. What a pity there was nothing like that to entertain the public for Comic Relief 2013.


None of those acts would ever appear on Comic Relief, Children In Need or any other big TV charity telethon event.
Well, except maybe the only name that I recognise from that lot, Jimmy Cricket ... although it isn't 1983 anymore!

The nearest any of the others might get to appearing on TV would probably be the auditions for BGT!

They wouldn't evcen get to the judges auditions on that. Tumble Tower also completely missing the point as Comic Relief had the UK's biggest illusionist perform a live stunt and numerous of the nations top comedians both live and in sketches throughout the night.
Last edited by Brekkie on 18 March 2013 7:17pm
DA
davidhorman
Comkic Relief had the UK's biggest illusionist perform a live stunt

I wouldn't call it a stunt, and I'd my eat my hat if it was live.
LL
Larry the Loafer
Comkic Relief had the UK's biggest illusionist perform a live stunt

I wouldn't call it a stunt, and I'd my eat my hat if it was live.


It was simple camera trickery. I think Dynamo is a great street magician but this stuff annoys the hell out of me.

Newer posts