TV Home Forum

Classic Doctor Who

(May 2007)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
JO
Johnny83
brotherton sands posted:
Johnny83 posted:
The Invasion is turning out to be a great episode so far, Cosgrove Hall did some excellent animation, wish they would re animate some of the other missing episodes as well


Episode 4 of "The Tenth Planet" has surely GOT to be the absolute top candidate for the Cosgrove Hall treatment!


Is that the only episode missing of the story?
ST
SillyTilly
Johnny83 posted:
Is that the only episode missing of the story?

Yes, sadly having the regeneration in it.
DA
davidhorman
The regeneration scene still exists though: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D5UWxU32NMA

David
CY
cylon6
davidhorman posted:
The regeneration scene still exists though: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D5UWxU32NMA

David
But annoyingly Troughton's very first story which was apparently one of his best has gone.

The story about how all of those Doctor Who episodes got lost just makes you want to cry. Every single episode existed right up to the 70's and then just before people could get their hands on them and save them, the tapes got junked!
JO
Johnny83
cylon6 posted:
davidhorman posted:
The regeneration scene still exists though: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D5UWxU32NMA

David
But annoyingly Troughton's very first story which was apparently one of his best has gone.

The story about how all of those Doctor Who episodes got lost just makes you want to cry. Every single episode existed right up to the 70's and then just before people could get their hands on them and save them, the tapes got junked!


I know rather ironic as at the time the BBC said that they were unlikely to repeat programmes Mad Laughing

As they said on the commentary to Episode 4 of The Invasion it's rather strange that episodes 1 & 4 are missing but the rest remain intact. It was a great story in the end, I did worry that they would be stretching it a bit with Eight episodes but the story never got boring and was great all round. As I have said before such a shame that so many Troughton stories have been lost.

After watching alot of classic Doctor Who episodes I have been able to rate my top 5 favourite Doctors, they are:

5. Jon Pertwee (to be fair I haven't watched many of his yet, hence his low entry)
4. Patrick Troughton (just watch him running & leaping away from the Cybermen in The Invasion Laughing )
3. Peter Davison (not everyone's cup of tea but The Caves of Androzani showed how great Peter Davison was in the role)
2. David Tennant (Series 3 alone has shown how great he is in the role)
1. Tom Baker (Who else, he IS The Doctor he did play the role long enough afterall)

I'm sure people will disagree with my list, especially Jon Pertwee's placement, but I have seen less of his stories compared to others. That being said all five were great Doctors IMHO.
ST
SillyTilly
I found this petition on outpost gallifrey for the BBC to show all doctor who episode in broadcast order on BBC FOUR.

http://www.petitiononline.com/kevster1/petition.html
CY
cylon6
(Quote removed)


I agree with your comment but I think it should be on the other thread. Very Happy
JO
Johnny83
(Quote removed)


Shame really, would rather they spent money on that than more reality shows Rolling Eyes

The Dalek Invasion of Earth was a rather interesting story, each part had it's own name and the "team" didn't seem to stik together that much throughout the story. The whole Doctor character seem more human as well, with it sounding rather odd with the Grandfather/Granddaughter relationship.

Another rather odd thing was that the Daleks had special devices fitted so they could mover without the metal track as well as the Robomen, which never seem to be used by the Daleks again (well not from the stories I have seen)

The Visitation was another great as well, the deisng of the android in it was so over the top but brilliant at the same time. It also had the "death" of the sonic screwdriver and also a cameo from John "I Say, I Say, Fred Elliot" Savident who I really wanted to be in it more & speak in his Fred Elliot accent Laughing

Survival was again a good story although yet again watching it with that title sequence and that film quality it reminded me too much of a CBBC series. Anthony Ainley was great as The Master as always, Ace had grown up so much since Rememberance of the Daleks and nice to see an appearance by Stouffer Laughing

The plans they had for Series 27 sounded rather good as well in the documentary on disc 2, shame it never happened but then again we wouldn't have the series we ended up with today had it not been cancelled when it was.
JO
Johnny83
Here's a good website, this person has made som excellent covers for adventures yet to be released, improved covers for ones already released (rememberance of the daleks) and some alternatives for the current run of Doctor Who.

Have a look
JO
Johnny83
Des Cartes posted:
How cheap is cheap? Has anyone heard any details of pricing?


Quite cheap actuallly:

http://amazon.co.uk/s/ref=sr_pg_2/202-4256075-3872649?ie=UTF8&rs=573406&sort=price&keywords=Doctor%20Who&rh=n%3A573406%2Ck%3ADoctor%20Who&page=2

Amazon Price for most £7.99 Very Happy Shame I've already got most of them Crying or Very sad
JO
Johnny83
Well after watching the other three Colin Baker DVD's that are currently available (The Mark of Rani, Vengance on Varos & The Two Doctors) I have to say that I have changed my mind about Colin Baker's Doctor.

I do actually like his Doctor, and two of the three stories were great (The Two Doctors was a bit iffy). I know some people didn't like the violent Doctor & didn't approve of him "attacking" his enemies but then again he was supposed to be a different Doctor. I like Peri as well, just a shame they cut her short like they did with Colin Baker.

Both of them come over as really nice, down to Earth people on the documentary on The Mark Of Rani DVD and I personally think it's a shame that they did put the show on hold for 18 months. Colin Baker was unrecognisable in the documentary, but Nicola Bryant had hardly changed at all in the last 25 years.

Also learnt something new on the documentary that Colin Baker did all of his own stunts, which apparently he was the only one of the old series that did.
TV
archiveTV
Loads of official clips now on

http://uk.youtube.com/user/BBCWorldwide

Newer posts