TV Home Forum

Children In Need 2018

A Night of fundraising again. (November 2018)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
JO
Jonwo
Dermot O' Leary would be my choice - definitely not divisive and probably the most professional and capable live television presenter we have to offer in the UK.

Which is precisely why X Factor rehired him pretty quickly after Flack and Murs who were like today's answer to the 1989 Brits.


The problem is that Dermot has other commitments and not just The X Factor but his Saturday Breakfast Radio 2 show. It's just isn't feasible for him to do the whole 1900-0000 and be able to up for a 7am Breakfast show the next day.
Jonwo posted:
If it was up to me, I would have Michael Mcintyre join Graham Norton, Mel Giedroyc, Rochelle and Marvin Humes for the 2019 event to air from The Theatre Royal, Drury Lane.

Michael would bring some best bits from his Big Show to Children in Need night, such as "Send to All". Have big musical guests. More audience participation.

The One Show item should be limited to a 10 minute Rickshaw Appeal item around 8.30pm.

More proper items should be made, specials of Eastenders of course, but bring back the BBC Newsreaders special routine, to go along with the usual Strictly Come Dancing episode.

The "previews" of Doctor Who and Call the Midwife should be real previews, not just a 90 second clip. Especially Doctor Who. Remember when the 2007 dedicated Children in Need sketch with Peter Davison and David Tennant?

The BBC needs to get ITV and Channel 4 to help, with specials from Corrie, Emmerdale etc.

We also need a musical item which links celebrities - remember the 1993 Comic Relief musical skit of Queen's Bohemian Rhapsody? For 2019, we would do something similar.

The show should end with a "Musicals Hour" from 12.00am-1.00am, with live performances of musicals on the Theatre Royal Stage. The Westend is right on their doorstep, so it would be not a hassle. Trying to get musicals from the Westend to Elstree must be a hassle?

Just some ideas, to bring a return-to-form for the telethon, because even though they are pulling in the millions, the presentation is truly dire, lacklustre and just plain lazy in many respects.


Drury Lane is out of action next year as it's being refurbished and I think most West End theatres aren't available on a Friday unless it's say the Palladium and that tends to be booked up as well.

I am sure one theatre would be available for just one Friday night in the year, especially the promotion they will get from hosting the event. It is only one night.


I imagine most theatre owners would rather have a Friday night performance of a West End show which generates revenue no just from ticket sales but also bar sales than host Children in Need.
JM
JamesM0984
Yep, youre not going to kick your major show out on a Friday evening!
DA
davidhorman
Jonwo posted:

The problem is that Dermot has other commitments and not just The X Factor but his Saturday Breakfast Radio 2 show. It's just isn't feasible for him to do the whole 1900-0000 and be able to up for a 7am Breakfast show the next day.


Pretty sure they could arrange for him to have one extra day off a year.
JK
JKDerry
Yep, youre not going to kick your major show out on a Friday evening!

One Friday night out of 52 Fridays, and for a charity event which Children in Need has a very special status, with over 6 million watching? Good publicity for the theatre involved I would suggest. Just my opinion.
MA
Markymark
Jonwo posted:

The problem is that Dermot has other commitments and not just The X Factor but his Saturday Breakfast Radio 2 show. It's just isn't feasible for him to do the whole 1900-0000 and be able to up for a 7am Breakfast show the next day.


Pretty sure they could arrange for him to have one extra day off a year.


Yep, or he could pre record his Saturday Breakfast show, it’s not like it’s packed with travel news and weather updates etc !
WH
Whataday Founding member
Yep, youre not going to kick your major show out on a Friday evening!

One Friday night out of 52 Fridays, and for a charity event which Children in Need has a very special status, with over 6 million watching? Good publicity for the theatre involved I would suggest. Just my opinion.


Plus a Wednesday get-in, Thursday rehearsals, Friday broadcast and Saturday get out, probably losing the matinee.
JO
Jonwo
Yep, youre not going to kick your major show out on a Friday evening!

One Friday night out of 52 Fridays, and for a charity event which Children in Need has a very special status, with over 6 million watching? Good publicity for the theatre involved I would suggest. Just my opinion.


Plus a Wednesday get-in, Thursday rehearsals, Friday broadcast and Saturday get out, probably losing the matinee.


Exactly plus theatre owners don’t care about publicity for the theatre itself as people go to the theatre for the show and not the theatre itself.
DE
DE88
Yep, youre not going to kick your major show out on a Friday evening!

One Friday night out of 52 Fridays, and for a charity event which Children in Need has a very special status, with over 6 million watching? Good publicity for the theatre involved I would suggest. Just my opinion.


With the very, *very* greatest of respect, there *is* the possibility that, no matter how clearly and concisely you make this point to the theatre owners, their reaction will be something like this... Embarassed Embarassed Smile

*

And as Brekkie says, it's not the location that's the issue with CIN - it's the content and the hosts. Even if a theatre owner *was* willing to open his/her doors to CIN, that wouldn't necessarily mean that the content would improve, or that the hosts would reduce in number and they wouldn't be divisive.

And if the content *was* still poor and there were still too many hosts, people would then be saying that booking a theatre was a terrible waste of licence fee money... Wink
IS
Inspector Sands
It's not that unfeasible, Comic Relief did their show a few years ago from The Palladium and it was the best one for years.

But that's Comic Relief, comedy belongs in a theatre. A theatre is the wrong setting for CiN.
DE88 and London Lite gave kudos
CA
Cando
The Palladium didn't have a regular booking then.
The last Comic Relief came from the theatre at the O2 and was a mess
JK
JKDerry
Well - anyone here have any ideas on how to do Children in Need better in 2019? I have suggested my own changes, but if anyone here thinks of anything better, please share. The show needs a revamp, but how? Let us know.
LL
London Lite Founding member
Well - anyone here have any ideas on how to do Children in Need better in 2019? I have suggested my own changes, but if anyone here thinks of anything better, please share. The show needs a revamp, but how? Let us know.


Scrap The One Show, start the show at 7pm and finish at 10 for the live show. The post 10pm slot can be used for CiN pre-recorded specials. Totals can be flashed up on screen intermittently using a voiceover between the shows.

During the live show, only one pair of presenters are on air for the whole three hours, giving continuity throughout the programme. It'll be tighter, but hopefully more entertaining as well as raising funds. Also the regional slots would be 2x10 minutes rather than the rushed three segments they get currently.

Newer posts