TV Home Forum

Charlie Brooker's Weekly Wipe

Split from Get Your Act Together (February 2015)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
CW
Charlie Wells Moderator
Looks like Charlie Brooker gave this programme [Get Your Act Together] a mention, skip to 11m16s...
http://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/b05173ym/charlie-brookers-weekly-wipe-series-3-episode-1
BR
Brekkie
Off topic but Weekly Wipe was disappointing this week,basically covering things The Last Leg had done better two weeks earlier.
VM
VMPhil
Off topic but Weekly Wipe was disappointing this week,basically covering things The Last Leg had done better two weeks earlier.

I'm starting to lose interest in it unfortunately. Been rewatching early Screenwipes to remember how much I used to love it.
DV
dvboy
You're not the only one.
Lots of people I've talked to have said how disappointed they are. Not do much Charlie Brooker but the other "characters"
BR
Brekkie
Philomena Cunk is the best thing about it at the moment. It might get better as the series goes on but this weeks just felt so out of date - they were obviously issues Charlie Brooker wanted to highlight but with a satirical show it has to be current otherwise there is no point.

To be honest I was quite surprised the series returned - I didn't think he was doing anymore.
AS
ASO
I thought Philomena Cunk's Moments of Wonder and the 'life of Zeb' things were great but some parts were weak. Not very current.
BR
Brekkie
That was my main issue - hopefully it'll pick up a bit now the series is underway, although not too much interesting to satire at the moment.
NJ
Neil Jones Founding member
Philomena Cunk is the best thing about it at the moment. It might get better as the series goes on but this weeks just felt so out of date - they were obviously issues Charlie Brooker wanted to highlight but with a satirical show it has to be current otherwise there is no point.


May have worked better as a standalone January Wipe based on that episode in all honesty.

I wonder if the gap between the 2014 Yearly Wipe and the new series was too long, as last year the gap between 2013 Wipe and the beginning of 2014 Weekly Wipe was 12 days. This year the gap between 2014 Wipe and 2015 Weekly Wipe is the best part of a month, hence the emphasis on the out-of-date stuff.

Still, new episode on Thursday, hopefully the show should sort itself out.
MS
Mr-Stabby
I still think the show is great, but like others have suggested elsewhere, i think the show would be better as a Monthly wipe, once a month throughout the year. Though from a practical point of view, that's a pretty difficult way to do it.
LL
Larry the Loafer
I think it lost a little something when it moved to BBC Two. As much as I like Weekly Wipe, I thought Screenwipe and Newswipe were thoroughly more enjoyable.
NJ
Neil Jones Founding member
I think it lost a little something when it moved to BBC Two. As much as I like Weekly Wipe, I thought Screenwipe and Newswipe were thoroughly more enjoyable.


Seems to be a trend for some reason when things move to BBC Two. When Apprentice You're Fired started on BBC Three it was enjoyable. Move it to BBC Two when the main show was promoted to BBC One and it just lost its mojo.

Same thing appears to have happened with Jack Whitehall's Backchat. The format's been tweaked and it doesn't quite work as well as it did when it was on BBC Three. Even Only Connect seems to have lost its sparkle, I feel and doesn't "feel" right on Two.
:-(
A former member
Add in Russel good news to that list.

Newer posts