TV Home Forum

BBC Two 2018 Revamp

New ident ‘Discovery’ - p89

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
OR
orange
He just didn’t like the new look, it’s a weird opinion but it’s his one, there’s no need for that messy outburst of insults.
RE
Revitt
Why is it a weird opinion?
WI
Wicko
Well, superb, beautiful new idents from BBC2. Professional endboards that look slick, modern and vibrant.
If BBC One just changed their endboards to something fresher and more in keeping with the Oneness theme, then that would be something of an improvement.

Dare I say it? BBC2 has the best ident package on telly! At least we might get a decent Christmas ident from them this year!
LL
Larry the Loafer
Easily pleased then.


We're just curious why you don't like them...?
DB
dbl
Why is it a weird opinion?

You're entitled to your opinion. But the vast majority including people from Creative industries think otherwise. - but again, it is your right. Might be helpful to expand on what you dislike about it.
RE
Revitt
Easily pleased then.


We're just curious why you don't like them...?


Sometimes you can't explain why you like or don't like something.
RE
Revitt
dbl posted:
Why is it a weird opinion?

You're entitled to your opinion. But the vast majority including people from Creative industries think otherwise. - but again, it is your right. Might be helpful to expand on what you dislike about it.


Indeed I am, and it's as valid as anyone's
WH
Whataday Founding member
Easily pleased then.


We're just curious why you don't like them...?


Sometimes you can't explain why you like or don't like something.


I've never ever experienced anyone on a TV presentation forum unable to explain why they don't like an ident.
CO
Conor98
It's weird how everyone else likes them.
I love the new idents. A great successor to the old 2s
LS
LoganStuff
Easily pleased then.


We're just curious why you don't like them...?


Sometimes you can't explain why you like or don't like something.

Then you basically have no reason to dislike the idents? You're entitled to your own opinion but it seems as if you just dislike the new set just for the sake of it.
MA
Markymark
dbl posted:
Why is it a weird opinion?

You're entitled to your opinion. But the vast majority including people from Creative industries think otherwise. - but again, it is your right. Might be helpful to expand on what you dislike about it.


You need to define what you mean by 'the vast majority' ? The vast majority of the UK population, or the vast majority of folk in here ? The vast majority of the population haven't even seen them yet, so will have no opinion. It's they these idents (should be) aimed at, not the so called creative industry or this forum.

Don't get me wrong, I'm not saying they are crap, or brilliant, or anything. They look quite slick to my eyes, but I've not actually seen them for real on my telly yet, so I reserve final judgement
JO
Joe
The unique element of this is the melding of trailers and idents together, the whole channel just flows now, perhaps for the first time I can recall on a mainstream service. Bonkers concept in theory but it works.


I take it you don’t watch much ITV then!

Newer posts