TV Home Forum

BBC1 Christmas 2017 Idents

Please - Don't (one)mess up the Christmas idents this year (November 2017)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
DP
D.Page
fanoftv posted:
That works very well. A brilliant use of the clips from the film.


Thanks. Probably only a matter of time before it gets pulled down though, as the intro uses footage from the 2 minute film (which is routinely being pulled down as soon as it's discovered on YT).
MR
mr_vivian
D.Page posted:
fanoftv posted:
That works very well. A brilliant use of the clips from the film.


Thanks. Probably only a matter of time before it gets pulled down though, as the intro uses footage from the 2 minute film (which is routinely being pulled down as soon as it's discovered on YT).


Very Good Work D Page - I like the way the film is edited seemlessly
ST
Stuart
lobster posted:
that's amazing, I thought it was cgi!

I did too.


I read some of this thread with complete astonishment at the comments by some people. The race of the characters or absence of the Mother really didn't even register with me at all.

They are just playful scenes about Christmas involving a Father and Daughter. It seems that some people want to read far too many things into what is actually just a humorous set of idents, which are cheerful and festive.
Last edited by Stuart on 9 December 2017 5:26pm - 3 times in total
DP
D.Page
mr_vivian posted:
D.Page posted:
fanoftv posted:
That works very well. A brilliant use of the clips from the film.


Thanks. Probably only a matter of time before it gets pulled down though, as the intro uses footage from the 2 minute film (which is routinely being pulled down as soon as it's discovered on YT).


Very Good Work D Page - I like the way the film is edited seemlessly


Each cut on the beat, and all dancing/foot tapping/hand gestures shown in the visuals timed to the tempo as best I could.
JB
JasonB
Looks like Oneness has been put to rest! (for now)
FL
flaziola
JasonB posted:
Looks like Oneness has been put to rest! (for now)

Get ready to Love 2018
ST
Stuart
flaziola posted:
JasonB posted:
Looks like Oneness has been put to rest! (for now)

Get ready to Love 2018

I do hope so. Even the repetitive "Love" idents/trailers are better than the dreadful oneness. Hopefully we won't be tortured again in 2018.
DP
D.Page
"Winning Weekend" comes round again on BBC1 (as it did last year), from Saturday. Special ident? I doubt it.
GM
nodnirG kraM
For anyone else who hadn't realised it was stop-motion animation rather than full CGI:



IS
Inspector Sands
fanoftv posted:
That works very well. A brilliant use of the clips from the film.

It works great, except for the narrative, one second they're not together and the next they are. A literal continuity error
DP
D.Page
nodnirG kraM posted:
For anyone else who hadn't realised it was stop-motion animation rather than full CGI:





Great stuff. It has been the biggest presentational surprise all year on BBC1 for me. The sheer amount of hard work and love that has gone into the making of this year's BBC1 Christmas pres is so unexpected, given the last few Christmases, and of course the Oneness tripe we've had all this year.
Stuart, CNash and Rex gave kudos
IS
Inspector Sands
Stuart posted:

I read some of this thread with complete astonishment at the comments by some people. The race of the characters or absence of the Mother really didn't even register with me at all.

It did with me but of course it didn't bother me.

My main thought about their race was I bet I know what part of London the creator lives in... he looks very familiar to me as an acrhitypal person from an area I know well

Newer posts