BBC1 Christmas 2017 Idents

I love it, absolutely fantastic package. The concept is great, the visuals are stunning and the music fits well.

It’s how ‘Oneness’ should have been from the very start. If the idea has to continue into 2018 then how about it gets done right and we’ll all just pretend 2017 didn’t happen.

Is there an alternate daytime version of that news ident? Not sure a moonlit landscape will work going into the One.

The trail is alright. Not very Christmassy, but then it is only the start of advent. CGI is a bit crap in places, the girl's head in particular.

The idents, except the news one, are rubbish.

Does the Kitchen news ident have music on the NI version?

Really not a fan of the promo - it's well made and a nice story but feels more like an ad for Britain's Got Talent than Christmas on BBC1.

However will say some of the cuts used for idents do seem to work pretty well, and as to be fair is often the case the news idents work especially well. I do just think it would be better if it didn't focus on one girl and her dad and instead had a few sets of characters used throughout the campaign.

The first TX of Kettle on NI did not have music.

Anyone on this thread struggling to see what's festive about the Washing Up ident clearly hasn't prepared Christmas lunch for a family of 12.

Nothing seems to be different for the regional opt-out on HD. Just the plain old swimmers, wheelchairs and so on.

NE&C used Kettle and West used Vista .

Presumably there's a daytime version? No idea just speculation.

Which one is Vista?

news .