CG
I have to say, the news ident is my favourite overall. I am enjoying this package. Not the best BBC One has ever had, but equally not the worst. 
CA
BBC ONE NI aired a variant with 'Symphony' in the background.
Now that's a lovely, (almost) silent ident to go into the news.
BBC ONE NI aired a variant with 'Symphony' in the background.
JO
BBC ONE NI aired a variant with 'Symphony' in the background.
Because music is the best way to start the news!
Now that's a lovely, (almost) silent ident to go into the news.
BBC ONE NI aired a variant with 'Symphony' in the background.
Because music is the best way to start the news!
MW
I really like this package.
Clearly a lot of effort and time has gone into producing it, unlike some previous years. The news ident is rather splendid, I like the subtlety and sombre tone used for it, and the colour palette is perfect.
Only thing annoying me is the 'BBC One' logotype, but as it stands I'm not sure how they could do much better (as I touched on earlier in the thread, maybe remove the BBC One legend entirely or have a subtle hint at it picked out in the 'live' action)
Clearly a lot of effort and time has gone into producing it, unlike some previous years. The news ident is rather splendid, I like the subtlety and sombre tone used for it, and the colour palette is perfect.
Only thing annoying me is the 'BBC One' logotype, but as it stands I'm not sure how they could do much better (as I touched on earlier in the thread, maybe remove the BBC One legend entirely or have a subtle hint at it picked out in the 'live' action)
VM
BBC ONE NI aired a variant with 'Symphony' in the background.
Huh, a bit odd - Scotland and Wales had no music but NI did.
Now that's a lovely, (almost) silent ident to go into the news.
BBC ONE NI aired a variant with 'Symphony' in the background.
Huh, a bit odd - Scotland and Wales had no music but NI did.
TO
This is exactly how I thought it should be done as I said in my post on page 37, so much nicer with the non-lyrical music added on, well done yet again NI on doing pres right.
Yeah the BBC One Northern Ireland version has more audio. Although it's still nicely calm, leading to something better than the silent variant on network and Scotland.
This is exactly how I thought it should be done as I said in my post on page 37, so much nicer with the non-lyrical music added on, well done yet again NI on doing pres right.
CY
They never used to be around long enough. Then there was The really horrible period in 89/90 where there didn’t turn up well into the evening on Christmas Eve on BBC1. I would prefer them appearing a week before Christmas as it doesn’t feel very Christmassy having them introduce Panorama.
It was always ridiculous going back to the boring normal globe on the 27th December.
As is blantently obvious these days it's a promotional tool first, ident second, so that'll be why the ident so launch at the same time as the promotions.
Was horrible when they were only on for 3 days. I think launching a week before Christmas then up to and including New Year's Day is the way to go.
My usual Scrooge comment ....
What is wrong with starting Christmas Presentation at 5pm on Christmas Eve, like the 'good old days'?
What is wrong with starting Christmas Presentation at 5pm on Christmas Eve, like the 'good old days'?
They never used to be around long enough. Then there was The really horrible period in 89/90 where there didn’t turn up well into the evening on Christmas Eve on BBC1. I would prefer them appearing a week before Christmas as it doesn’t feel very Christmassy having them introduce Panorama.
It was always ridiculous going back to the boring normal globe on the 27th December.
As is blantently obvious these days it's a promotional tool first, ident second, so that'll be why the ident so launch at the same time as the promotions.
Was horrible when they were only on for 3 days. I think launching a week before Christmas then up to and including New Year's Day is the way to go.
GM
nodnirG kraM
Your return is the best thing that happened to TV Forum this year.
Mods disagree. I have been warned!
What a pity this forum is still run in the same childish way it always was.
See ya, chaps.