TV Home Forum

BBC1 Christmas 2017 Idents

Please - Don't (one)mess up the Christmas idents this year (November 2017)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
:-(
A former member
You've got to admire the detail in the ident - even down to the information scrolling across the radio's display.
GM
nodnirG kraM
(although he gets bonus points for having his device in landscape).

You see, it's this level of quality journalistic professionalism that I've come to reply on you for, iSon.
BA
bilky asko
Doesn't do a lot for me. I'm getting bored of these tortured sequences where it all builds up to an optimistic crescendo only for a personal tragedy to jeopardise that happy ending. I'm not a Scrooge, but it always turns out alright so why invest into anyway? A slushy rom com where you've given 90 minutes of your life may be worth a wry smile once the protagonists eventually (and predictably) get together in the final scene... but I'd prefer to see something a little more hopeful from the start.

Besides, the father is a right dick for ignoring his daughter throughout the sequence and his only act is to film her performance through a phone (although he gets bonus points for having his device in landscape).


He helps her defeat her stage fright by reminding her of her routine.
CA
Cavan
Doesn't do a lot for me. I'm getting bored of these tortured sequences where it all builds up to an optimistic crescendo only for a personal tragedy to jeopardise that happy ending. I'm not a Scrooge, but it always turns out alright so why invest into anyway? A slushy rom com where you've given 90 minutes of your life may be worth a wry smile once the protagonists eventually (and predictably) get together in the final scene... but I'd prefer to see something a little more hopeful from the start.

Besides, the father is a right dick for ignoring his daughter throughout the sequence and his only act is to film her performance through a phone (although he gets bonus points for having his device in landscape).


He helps her defeat her stage fright by reminding her of her routine.

Which shows that he wasn't ignoring her at all.
JO
Jon
Try greedy companies who will use any reason to jack up prices and slash content.

You voted to give them that ‘excuse’.
DP
D.Page
Best BBC1 Christmas pres package since 2014. The only thing, for me, is that is doesn't feel Chrismassy enough. Snow clearly visible at the edges of the window with this first ident would have helped here.
AlexEdohHD13 and Rex gave kudos
RE
Rex
Best BBC1 Christmas pres package since 2014.

Hear hear.

Getting ready to record another junction...
GM
nodnirG kraM
Getting ready to record another junction...

May I suggest spaghetti?

http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2012/05/24/article-2149198-13436BEF000005DC-581_964x637.jpg
RE
Rex
Getting ready to record another junction...

May I suggest spaghetti?

http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2012/05/24/article-2149198-13436BEF000005DC-581_964x637.jpg

I'll order a nice dinner of that, please. Laughing
JO
Josh
Christmas Lights sting just now.
:-(
A former member
Wow a sting that was nice,
JA
Jake
Did we get a glimpse of Reith?

Edit: Nope

Newer posts