TV Home Forum

BBC1 Christmas 2017 Idents

Please - Don't (one)mess up the Christmas idents this year (November 2017)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
IS
Inspector Sands
Asa posted:
That is a really nice film and such a refreshing break from the normal dreary idents/stings. Better than Sprout Boy for me even though there is literally no link to the BBC (it could well be for any department store).

Not much of a Christmas link either, take away the incidental decorations and it could be anytime of the year
CR
Critique
Is it just me that half expected that they were going to edit the final notes to Symphony to fit into the old BBC One three note motif? Had this been 2016 and pre-Oneness I'd have been calling it a missed opportunity?
KU
Kunst
My usual Scrooge comment ....

What is wrong with starting Christmas Presentation at 5pm on Christmas Eve, like the 'good old days'?

1) Now Christmas idents are more expensive than they used to be, so that BBC obviously prefer to show them for a longer period of time

2) Christmas atmosphere and Christmas shows happen more before Christmas than on the Christmas day itself these days
3) It's obviously all part of a general commercial push to let you spend more money, and BBC "subconsciously" is influenced Very Happy
4) Last but not least, isn't that great to have a break from your usual Oneness boredom?

BTW disgressing a little bit, here in Italy most channels decide to put on their Christmas look on the 8th of December, which is a national holiday here (Immacolata/Feast of the Immaculate Conception), and it's usually the traditional day when people put their Christmas decorations up.. however, some people decide to put their decorations up earlier than this these days, so some channels behave similarly
VM
VMPhil
When the BBC didn’t start Christmas idents until Christmas Eve, how long beforehand did they start running Christmas branded trails?
JC
JCB
Why BBC 1 feels it needs to follow John Lewis' lead to promote Christmas telly I have no idea. Rolling Eyes
HC
Hatton Cross
My usual Scrooge comment ....

What is wrong with starting Christmas Presentation at 5pm on Christmas Eve, like the 'good old days'?


No Pres B to put the mechanical models for BBC One & Two on a table and point a Link 125 at each?
MR
mr_vivian
JCB posted:
Why BBC 1 feels it needs to follow John Lewis' lead to promote Christmas telly I have no idea. Rolling Eyes


It is very strange and it's obvious they are copying John Lewis.

BBC is where you want to come to escape all of that marketing rubbish.

I blame Brexit for this oneness stuff as they seem to think we're a divided nation. It is totally fine for the nation to have different views and that's what they should be embracing.
WI
Wicko
JCB posted:
Why BBC 1 feels it needs to follow John Lewis' lead to promote Christmas telly I have no idea. Rolling Eyes


It is very strange and it's obvious they are copying John Lewis.

BBC is where you want to come to escape all of that marketing rubbish.

I blame Brexit for this oneness stuff as they seem to think we're a divided nation. It is totally fine for the nation to have different views and that's what they should be embracing.


Brexit is being blamed on the fact that fewer people in the UK eating Brussels sprouts too. In fact, lavatory paper seems to have gone from 240 sheets per roll to 180 sheets per roll so maybe that should be blamed on Brexit too.
:-(
A former member
Try greedy companies who will use any reason to jack up prices and slash content.
OR
orange
If oneness continues in January I’m going to move to country we’re channels have decent presentation

Good. Bye then.
At least that's one less person out the way who can't spell basic words (or be bothered to spell check) so that it forces the reader to decipher the original meaning of the dribble you intended to pollute the Internet with in the first place.

Congratulations, you overreacted to an overreaction.
P0
p0ab
When the BBC didn’t start Christmas idents until Christmas Eve, how long beforehand did they start running Christmas branded trails?

I recall in 1992 and 1993 it was December 1st.
WL
W1LL
Hopefully we've just seen the last of Oneness, with Skaters leading into Pointless.

Newer posts