TV Home Forum

BBC1 Christmas 2017 Idents

Please - Don't (one)mess up the Christmas idents this year (November 2017)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
:-(
A former member
Looks to me like she sees its the Oneness and become even more disappointed...

Here's a clue.

Newsroom24 and Argybargy gave kudos
RE
Rex
Wicko posted:
Jake posted:
It's early this year. I think it was later last year. They must have realised we all need a good break from Oneness.

Potentially the end of Oneness?


When was the last time they launched new Oneness idents? August or September?

August, with Fell Runners and Llama Trekkers.

Nothing has been added since then.
WI
Wicko
Wicko posted:
I think the Circles will return on Jan 1st. Just a hunch.

I doubt it Wicko. January 1st and it'll be back to Oneness.


Exercise Class and swimmers to make a welcome return! How excited we'll all be!
MR
mr_vivian
Oneness has already been confirmed as a "year-long" collaboration project for BBC Creative so I'd be bemused to see Oneness back in January.
RE
Rex
Wicko posted:
I think the Circles will return on Jan 1st. Just a hunch.

I doubt it Wicko. January 1st and it'll be back to Oneness.

Wishful thinking, but I'm hoping to see Oneness taken off air by the end of this year. Makes no sense to carry on from next year onwards, as it was said to be a year-long collaboration. Keeping the terrible idents but removing the Oneness tagline only exacerbates what is an already dull set, with no underlying theme or even any relation to the channel's ethos and programming.

Circles coming back? It would be strange to do so, especially with news outlets at the start of the year talking about the end of those idents. But it could work. As a stopgap.

The way I see it - either an old set as a stopgap or a major overhaul of One and Two.
KU
Kunst
If they don't want to work on new idents, they should just bring back the circles

I know some despised them, but, in actual branding terms, and compared to the branding of many other countries' public services, they were pretty well made (only SRF1 came close enough: except for the soundtrack, which is very monotonous).. a shame to let them go for a much much inferior package

I also can't understand why they didn't keep adding more idents based on that concept
MR
mr_vivian
Wicko posted:
I think the Circles will return on Jan 1st. Just a hunch.

I doubt it Wicko. January 1st and it'll be back to Oneness.

Wishful thinking, but I'm hoping to see Oneness taken off air by the end of this year. Makes no sense to carry on from next year onwards, as it was said to be a year-long collaboration. Keeping the terrible idents but removing the Oneness tagline only exacerbates what is an already dull set, with no underlying theme or even any relation to the channel's ethos and programming.

Circles coming back? It would be strange to do so, especially with news outlets at the start of the year talking about the end of those idents. But it could work. As a stopgap.

The way I see it - either an old set as a stopgap or a major overhaul of One and Two.


I think Oneness was the cheap stopgap and the stopgap for BBC2 is showing the old ones.

There's a greater possibility now we'll get a brand new look for 1 and 2. It's the only conclusion you can come to when they've stopped the Circles for some reason and BBC 2 has been showing old Idents for a few years now.

Going back to Oneness or the Circles would be odd.
CY
cylon6
Wicko posted:
Wicko posted:
I think the Circles will return on Jan 1st. Just a hunch.

I doubt it Wicko. January 1st and it'll be back to Oneness.


Exercise Class and swimmers to make a welcome return! How excited we'll all be!

😨😨😨😨😨
SP
Spencer
Oneness has already been confirmed as a "year-long" collaboration project for BBC Creative so I'd be bemused to see Oneness back in January.


'A year-long collaboration' just refers to the fact that they're collaborating with Martin Parr in making the idents over the course of the year. It doesn't necessarily mean they'll stop showing them after the year is over.

For all we know, they might still be making idents as part of the year-long collaboration at the moment, ready to be shown next year. But until January comes, we simply don't know either way.
WI
Wicko
Looks like we have an idea of BBC1's festive endboards now, the Christmas Webpage has now updated.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p037pf38
JA
Jake
Here's a clue.



MR
mr_vivian
Oneness has already been confirmed as a "year-long" collaboration project for BBC Creative so I'd be bemused to see Oneness back in January.


'A year-long collaboration' just refers to the fact that they're collaborating with Martin Parr in making the idents over the course of the year. It doesn't necessarily mean they'll stop showing them after the year is over.

For all we know, they might still be making idents as part of the year-long collaboration at the moment, ready to be shown next year. But until January comes, we simply don't know either way.


Well obviously we don't know. That's why I've said I'd be bemused if they came back.

Newer posts