TV Home Forum

BBC1 Christmas 2017 Idents

Please - Don't (one)mess up the Christmas idents this year (November 2017)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
FO
FanOfTV99
This was just on BBC One
*


OMG They must have took my idea for having a Animated Oneness
DB
dbl
Hmm. No
DP
D.Page
BBC1, 8.59pm:

ToasterMan and paul_hadley gave kudos
RE
Rex
This was just on BBC One
*

Looks lovely from first impressions, and indicates a bigger sense of ambition for this year's presentation.

I have to be careful of expectations regarding the latter part of what I have wrote - BBC One teased Sprout Boy in the days leading up to 2015's Christmas presentation and although BBC Creative executives saw the campaign to be effective, reception was mixed, judging from previous posts I've read.
ToasterMan and paul_hadley gave kudos
BM
BlipTheMerciless
Hate to say it but, don't set your expectations too high.

I’d like to ask, is it connected to the either the Circle or Oneness theme, or is it an entirely different concept?

Not quite oneness, in fact less about the concept of coming together this year.
JC
JCB
Presumably it's another John Lewis inspired mini film a la Sprout Boy. Hopefully the actual idents will be better this time round though.
JO
Jonny
Will it have as magical a soundtrack as this?

BBC2 - should go back to either the 2011 or 2007 full sets or use the old soundtracks as was, if no budget for anything new. Brand continues to be mismanaged/allowed to free fall.
WI
Wicko
I wouldn't have minded BBC2 going back to the Christmas Sprite idents. At least they were slick. Even True Christmas which is a cheap as chips channel, created new Christmas idents!
AR
Argybargy
Even a variety of older BBC Two Christmas idents would suffice, not the same ones we've seen for the last 2 years- there are plenty to choose from. And let's hear them with their ORIGINAL soundtracks. The 1990s ones were particularly memorable and would still fit in with the ongoing retro branding.
WI
Wicko
Even a variety of older BBC Two Christmas idents would suffice, not the same ones we've seen for the last 2 years- there are plenty to choose from. And let's hear them with their ORIGINAL soundtracks. The 1990s ones were particularly memorable and would still fit in with the ongoing retro branding.


I really liked this package from 1994. That would fit in with todays branding quite well.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=teosLHOKNQs
Last edited by Wicko on 30 November 2017 12:04am
PA
paul_hadley
Back when BBC1 used to care - https://www.facebook.com/BBCOne/videos/856904704329949/

Hopefully something decent this year looking at those ident previews in the thread...
LL
Larry the Loafer
I have a sinking feeling that all the good stuff will be saved for the promos and the ident won't be that good. Like with the 2012 package, the promo seemed quite promising compared to the ident that came as a result.

Newer posts