TV Home Forum

BBC One HD This Autumn

Split from the generic thread (May 2010)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
NE
newsatten
Eastenders tonight on BBC One HD made it's Train scene look SHOCKING with it's green screen window work. Laughing

When it's on iPlayer I suggest people look for it just for a giggle!


God I know! All the family was like - "god how fake does that look!" Laughing

30 days later

DA
davidhorman
I've just noticed BBC One HD is currently DOGless (showing Total Wipeout). Have they finally decided to use the DOG as a true HD indicator?

David
FU
fusionlad Founding member
I've just noticed BBC One HD is currently DOGless (showing Total Wipeout). Have they finally decided to use the DOG as a true HD indicator?

David


I was wondering the same. ITV have always been good for removing the DOG for non HD programmes. ITV have also made their logos much more transparent.
DA
davidhorman
Something else that's weird... that "BBC One has never looked so good" thing for HD with Alan Sugar, Dot Cotton, Daleks et al... doesn't look good. To me it doesn't look much better than upscaled SD, and it looks like it was made at film rate and then had a video effect applied to it - I keep my thinking my TV's "smooth" function has kicked in by itself, which it sometimes does - Jake's keepy-uppies are smooth, but then when Alex opens the box it's all back to film speed.

ETA: DOG's back for Magicians. Maybe they make an exception for Total Wipeout because the picture quality's so awful, they can't even try to pass it off as HD...

David
FU
fusionlad Founding member
Something else that's weird... that "BBC One has never looked so good" thing for HD with Alan Sugar, Dot Cotton, Daleks et al... doesn't look good. To me it doesn't look much better than upscaled SD, and it looks like it was made at film rate and then had a video effect applied to it - I keep my thinking my TV's "smooth" function has kicked in by itself, which it sometimes does - Jake's keepy-uppies are smooth, but then when Alex opens the box it's all back to film speed.

David


I don't think 'the bits between the programmes' are ever HD are they? So that includes any HD promotion.
FU
fusionlad Founding member
I've just noticed BBC One HD is currently DOGless (showing Total Wipeout). Have they finally decided to use the DOG as a true HD indicator?

David


DOG back on for the HD transmission of 'The Magicians'. So your theory appears a good one at the moment.
AC
aconnell
Why is it that only the programmes on BBC One HD are in HD, and not the menus and trailers etc? The difference is very striking!

16 days later

DV
DVB Cornwall
Can anyone confirm my suspicion that BAFTA only have limited access to HD clips tonight and as a result most are upscaled SD?
WE
Westy2
I gather at 8pm a weather forecast is now broadcast in place of the regional news on HD.

I know Inside Out is rotated by region each week.

Has anything else replaced the other 'regional slots' on HD or is it still the red caption?
OV
Orry Verducci
Has anything else replaced the other 'regional slots' on HD or is it still the red caption?

On one occasion I did see BBC HD Preview, with BBC One branding, replace the regional news, with a caption overlayed along the bottom of the screen saying to change to 101/1 for the news.
NW
nwtv2003
Has anything else replaced the other 'regional slots' on HD or is it still the red caption?

On one occasion I did see BBC HD Preview, with BBC One branding, replace the regional news, with a caption overlayed along the bottom of the screen saying to change to 101/1 for the news.


That's usually at 6.30pm on weekdays, with Come Fly With Me being the final preview. All other Regional bulletins have the red caption, it's only Inside Out and I think The Politics Show that have some Regional output on BBC One HD.
AG
AxG
Can anyone confirm my suspicion that BAFTA only have limited access to HD clips tonight and as a result most are upscaled SD?


Even watching in SD, some of the Harry Potter film clips looked quite bad.

Newer posts