TV Home Forum

BBC One HD This Autumn

Split from the generic thread (May 2010)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
ST
Stuart
Granada being an ITV HD region so that's not unexpected. In the SW we get London on ITV1 HD.

That may be the case on Freeview, but on Sky and VM, we get the Central region on ITV1 HD in the South West.
NW
nwtv2003
BBC One HD placeholder is now on Virgin Media channel 108, whilst BBC HD has been moved to 187.
BR
Brekkie
That DOG is ridiculously oversized! Shocked


Hmm. I don't normally go in for conspiracy theories, but...

Does anyone else ever get the feeling that a channel decides on how it wants its DOG to look, and then launches with a stupidly large, coloured or bright version? Then, they tone it down a few weeks later to look as they originally intended, so that those who've complained (and would complain about any DOG) feel like they've achieved a victory and shut up, on the basis that 'it's not as bad as it was'.

Or at least, they test the water with something truly obtrusive just to see how much they can get away with.

It does seem that way.
AB
aberdeenboy
I will bet 50p that the DOG being used at the moment will be scaled down considerably before next Wednesday...

If it isn't, I'll bet £5 it will be changed within a fortnight of launch.
OV
Orry Verducci
I will bet 50p that the DOG being used at the moment will be scaled down considerably before next Wednesday...

If it isn't, I'll bet £5 it will be changed within a fortnight of launch.

I wouldn't be so sure. To me it looks like the DOG has been made that size to ensure the "HD" tag on the logo is readable, especially on 720p televisions. As long as the logo is using that poor attempt to add HD branding, I imagine the DOG will stay.
CH
Chie
I will bet 50p that the DOG being used at the moment will be scaled down considerably before next Wednesday...

If it isn't, I'll bet £5 it will be changed within a fortnight of launch.

The period between now and next Wednesday is within a fortnight of launch. Confused

So you are actually betting £5.50 that the DOG will be scaled down by next Wednesday?
JO
Joe
I hope you're just being pedantic and not dense. Wink
AB
aberdeenboy
Er... I think the normal definition of launch would be 7pm next Wednesday and not the start of test transmissions, the appearance of a placeholder or whatever. lol
DV
dvboy
When will the channel appear on Freeview HD?


The same day as all the others, 3rd November at 7pm with The One Show


I mean will it appear in advance of 7pm, with a holding card?


Well posters on the 'other' forum are saying that it will appear before the day because the place holder on Sky says that BBC HD has moved to 169. Hope this helps


Not on my Sky, it hasn't.

Someone I follow on Twitter posted that on BBC HD the continuity announcer over the end of the Apprentice reminded people to change their Series Link to BBC 1 HD.
CH
Chie
I see. The DOG is very translucent - I can't see many people complaining about it to be honest.
NG
noggin Founding member
Chie posted:
I see. The DOG is very translucent - I can't see many people complaining about it to be honest.


Oh - just you wait... It may be translucent - but it is also HUGE...
JO
Jonny
It's not surprising given the current BBC One logo was likely created without DOG suitability in mind. The position and size of the BBC logo next to the 'One' makes for an awkward DOG proposition; I doubt they could decrease its size without making the BBC logo (and certainly the all-important, ill-designed 'HD' tag) illegible.

The solution would be to resize the 'HD' badge to match the 'One', shift it directly alongside the 'One' and reduce the size of the whole thing, accepting that the BBC logo may become less readable. I can't think of another alternative that wouldn't involve tweaking the core logo.

Newer posts