TV Home Forum

BBC One Continuity Now Pre-Recorded?

(February 2005)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
IS
Inspector Sands
tvarksouthwest posted:
marksi posted:
Cost.

Then maybe the cost of live and recorded annos should be the same?


What do you mean 'should be' - something costs what something costs, you can't just decide that something is cheaper or more expensive than it is.

A machine is cheaper than a human - basic economics
NG
noggin Founding member
tvarksouthwest posted:
marksi posted:
Cost.

Then maybe the cost of live and recorded annos should be the same?


Err - how?

Surely you can see that it is cheaper to bring in one person for a couple of hours to record all the announcements back to back, than pay two or three people to sit in a booth, making only a couple of announcements an hour.

It is cheaper to pay one person to do a job rather than three.

I'm not saying the result is as good - but there is little argument that it is cheaper, unless you pay live con annos 1/3 the amount of money as a recorded announcer...
TV
TVDragon
Wales on 1 played out one of the celebration sport symbols just then -- when it was yesterday that Wales won.

Surely it wasn't played because England lost?

Mind you at least it's never recorded. You can also tell an anno is live when they actually sound tired at 3am, instead of unnaturally hyper.
RU
Ruski
TVDragon posted:


Mind you at least it's never recorded. You can also tell an anno is live when they actually sound tired at 3am, instead of unnaturally hyper.


Didn't think anyone noticed. Laughing
TV
tvarksouthwest
noggin posted:
Surely you can see that it is cheaper to bring in one person for a couple of hours to record all the announcements back to back, than pay two or three people to sit in a booth, making only a couple of announcements an hour.

It is cheaper to pay one person to do a job rather than three.

What's cheaper isn't necessarily desirable - and recent problems have illustrated this perfectly!
MB
Mark Boulton
Live announcers, particularly on ITV, weren't idle in the time between announcements. They were liasing with the VT and telecine areas to get the next programme ready for broadcast. They'd talk about the programme that was on and the forthcoming programmes with their colleagues throughout the building, and distill it into an essence which they could deliver as a considered but compact synopsis of the programme they're going to announce, or promote, next.

They could also be going through viewer's letters or be on the phone to the local newspapers or council, charities, schools or other organisations to find out more about events they'd asked them to promote verbally, as items that might be of interest to those resident in the region.

Live announcers, particularly in-vision ones, used to have MUCH more to do than just deliver the announcements, and it was a full working day.

The behind the scenes stuff was stuff that they enjoyed, and gave the job a bit more purpose than just being a voice-over artist.

Why do announcements have to be done by highly-paid voice-over artists anyway? An announcer should relate to the viewer, not sound as if they're announcing trains at a railway station.
IS
Inspector Sands
Mark Boulton posted:
Live announcers, particularly on ITV, weren't idle in the time between announcements. They were liasing with the VT and telecine areas to get the next programme ready for broadcast.


Wouldn't that be the job of the gallery team, especially the director?
SK
skyisthebest
Two special BBC ONE Wales St Davids Day idents are showing tonight. Just incase you didnt know....
One features school children and the other features a flag falling down from the roof of the Millenuim Stadium.
JV
James Vertigan Founding member
Nice still of the Masai ident just now - froze on the opening frame - announcement obviously pre-recorded as announcer didn't falter...
SD
Steve D
James Vertigan posted:
Nice still of the Masai ident just now - froze on the opening frame - announcement obviously pre-recorded as announcer didn't falter...


No, it was a live announcement. He didn't falter because he's good at his job!
CW
Charlie Wells Moderator
*wonders who's doing the BBC Continuity today* Laughing
RU
Ruski
Charlie Wells posted:
*wonders who's doing the BBC Continuity today* Laughing


Depends which of the nations you are referring to?

Newer posts