TV Home Forum

BBC loses Great British Bake Off

UPDATE: Mel and Sue quit as hosts (September 2016)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
SW
Steve Williams
I guess at least with the Top/Fifth Gear scenario it was the case of the BBC axing it and the show getting a new home, unlike Saturday Kitchen/Cooks which was a GBBO scenario of a current and popular show being poached while still in production.


That's right - a bit like when half the Human League left and all they had left was Phil Oakey and the name. One for the teenagers, there (a bit like Danny Baker tweeting last night that Bake Off was Brian Poole and the Beeb were the Tremeloes). In the Top Gear scenario, the Beeb had decided to "rest" the show as a regular weekly thing so everyone involved decided to take it to another broadcaster. It would be a bit like if when Top of the Pops ended the entire production team all then went to do a similar show on another channel.

The Thames Dallas affair was mentioned earlier, I'm not sure if everyone knows that story. That was when Thames decided to poach Dallas and offer the distributors an obscene amount of money, to a massive furore because the gentlemen's agreement was that broadcasters didn't get involved in bidding wars because it meant prices would spiral to unrealistic amounts, and the other ITV regions, most notably Yorkshire, said they wouldn't show it because they thought it had been conducted in a shabby and underhand manner. In the end Thames had to give it back.

Someone I follow on Twitter suggested yesterday they would put a tenner on the next series of Bake Off being on BBC1. That was before it was announced it was moving to C4, but I think the odds might have shortened a bit since.
Inspector Sands and tightrope78 gave kudos
SW
Steve Williams
I liked Huw Edwards tweeting this...



WH
Whataday Founding member
Suggestion for Mel & Sue replacement.... French & Saunders?
SE
Square Eyes Founding member
Suggestion for Mel & Sue replacement.... French & Saunders?


It's C4 so Kirstie & Phil.
:-(
A former member
Does anyone think CH4 may have enter talks just to see what it could get from love? Im sure a few companies do that just to get talks with the indies?
JC
JCB
I liked Huw Edwards tweeting this...





Yep, it's days like this that all that "born risky" we're-edgier-than-you overstatement comes back to bite 4 on it's arse.
GO
gottago
Does anyone think CH4 may have enter talks just to see what it could get from love? Im sure a few companies do that just to get talks with the indies?

It's the indies that fight over each other to get meetings with channel commissioners to talk about new programme ideas (if that's what you mean), not the other way round.
WH
Whataday Founding member
Suggestion for Mel & Sue replacement.... French & Saunders?


It's C4 so Kirstie & Phil.


It would be a hell of a u-turn:



JO
Jonny
Suggestion for Mel & Sue replacement.... French & Saunders?


It's C4 so Kirstie & Phil.

New vehicle for Noel.
UB
UBox
The question is: what limitations are there on BBC launching a new baking show with the Bake Off cast and let Channel Four keep their tent?
DA
davidhorman
Jonny posted:

New vehicle for Noel.


If I say "from Crinkly Bottom to Soggy Bottom" now, will that make it copyrighted and stop anyone else from using it, ever?
AS
Asa Admin
I think they'll be many in the industry pondering over this one for a while. Whilst things like The Voice and Top Gear team changes aren't a shock, there are not that many examples of programmes that are so associated with one broadcaster being effectively pinched by another. A lesson to all broadcasters who buy off indies I suppose.

I haven't seen any trails for it tonight. Admittedly I haven't caught every junction but it wouldn't surprise me if they've not even shown as much as a sting to promote the programme. Maybe tomorrow night just needs a defiant "This is BBC One" introduction.

Newer posts